# United States v. Koch

Jack and Steven Koch, co-owners of Fresh N Clear, which sold household goods online, bought Priority Mail Flat Rate Envelope labels, electronically removed the line marking them Flat Rate, and put them on boxes that didn't qualify, keeping about $3 million in postage from USPS from January to September 2020. [2]

- Scheme: Altered postage
- Docket: No. 2:21-cr-00930 (D.N.J.)
- Investigated by: The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
- Newest source: December 4, 2025

## The scheme

Priority Mail Flat Rate Envelope postage is one price to any address in the country, for an item that fits in the USPS envelope and weighs 70 pounds or less. [3] Other labels don't have to show the postage paid in a form a person can read. A Flat Rate Envelope label must carry the words “FLAT RATE ENV”, so a USPS employee can check that the piece weighs 70 pounds or less and fits the envelope. [3] The defendants bought Flat Rate labels and electronically removed the endorsement, the line that showed a package qualified for the Flat Rate price. [2] They put the altered labels on packages that didn't qualify for the Flat Rate price and would have cost more to mail, and Fresh N Clear shipped them to its customers. [2] When they were charged, the release said the labels were altered to send large household goods that wouldn't fit in the envelope, such as cases of bottled water, laundry detergent and cases of soda, at the flat rate. [1] Without the endorsement, a box looked as if it had paid the right postage, the complaint says. [3]

- Jack Koch and Fresh N Clear LLC: One of its owners. [3]
- Steven Koch and Fresh N Clear LLC: A co-owner. [5]
- Fresh N Clear LLC and Better Shopping: Sold on Amazon under this name. [3]
- Fresh N Clear LLC and Amazon ePostage: Mailed about 30,000 parcels a month on postage bought this way, the complaint says. [3]

## How it came to light

- February 25, 2020: On eight days from February to August 2020, law enforcement examined about 1,000 Fresh N Clear parcels, and about 97% had altered labels, the complaint says. [3]
- September 22, 2020: Law enforcement searched Fresh N Clear's warehouse with a warrant and found 225 Priority Mail parcels, 223 of them with altered labels, the complaint says. [3]
- September 22, 2020: During the search, law enforcement questioned Steven Koch and a witness, the complaint says. [3]
- Investigators looked at Fresh N Clear's Amazon listings and saw goods that wouldn't fit in a Flat Rate Envelope, such as cases of water, laundry detergent and cases of soda, the complaint says. [3]
- Investigators reviewed Amazon's shipping records and found Fresh N Clear bought about 240,471 Priority Mail labels from January to September 2020, almost all at the Flat Rate Envelope price, the complaint says. [3]

## What showed they knew

Said so, in their own words. Steven Koch told law enforcement that he and Jack Koch altered the labels to keep Fresh N Clear competitive with other online sellers, the complaint says.

> S.KOCH further advised that the Defendants altered the postage labels in order to keep Fresh N Clear competitive with other e-commerce businesses. [3]

## Amounts

- Postage lost: approximately $3 million, postage revenue the defendants kept from USPS, January to September 2020. [2]
- Postage lost: at least $6 million, postage revenue the complaint estimated USPS lost, January to September 2020. [3]
- Restitution: $3,500,000, restitution ordered by the amended judgment in Jack Koch's case. [6]
- Restitution: $3,500,000, restitution ordered by the amended judgment in Steven Koch's case. [7]
- How many: 240,471, USPS Priority Mail labels Fresh N Clear bought from January to September 2020, almost all at the Flat Rate Envelope price. [1]
- How many: approximately 30,000 parcels per month, parcels Fresh N Clear mailed on postage bought through Amazon. [3]
- How many: approximately 1,000 parcels, Fresh N Clear parcels law enforcement examined on eight days in 2020, about 97% of them with altered labels. [3]
- How many: 223, parcels with altered labels, of the 225 Priority Mail parcels found in a search of Fresh N Clear's warehouse. [3]
- Postage lost: $91.23, postage lost on one box, mailed on a $7.15 Flat Rate Envelope label bought on or about February 25, 2020. [3]
- Postage lost: approximately $98.37, postage short on the package Steven Koch's mail fraud count names, which needed about $105.52. [5]

## Where it stands

Jack Koch and Steven Koch were each sentenced on September 13, 2022 to 3 months in prison and 3 years of supervised release, and the amended judgment of October 19, 2022 in each case ordered $3,500,000 in restitution, as of the last entries in their dockets, of October 14, 2025 and December 4, 2025. [6]

### United States v. Jack Koch

One of the owners of Fresh N Clear LLC. [3]

- Charged: theft of government funds, count 1, 18 U.S.C. §§ 641 and 2 [3]
- Charged: forged postage, count 2, 18 U.S.C. §§ 501 and 2 [3]
- Charged: mail fraud, count 1, 18 U.S.C. § 1341 [4]
- December 1, 2020: Charged by complaint with one count of theft of government funds and one count of postage stamp fraud. [1]
- December 1, 2020: Arrested. [6]
- December 20, 2021: Pleaded guilty to mail fraud. [2]
- September 13, 2022: Sentenced to 3 months in prison and 3 years of supervised release, with restitution to be set within 90 days. [6]
- October 19, 2022: Ordered to pay $3,500,000 in restitution, in an amended judgment that left the prison term and the supervised release as they were. [6]

### United States v. Steven Koch

A co-owner of Fresh N Clear LLC. [5]

- Charged: theft of government funds, count 1, 18 U.S.C. §§ 641 and 2 [3]
- Charged: forged postage, count 2, 18 U.S.C. §§ 501 and 2 [3]
- Charged: mail fraud, count 1, 18 U.S.C. § 1341 [5]
- December 1, 2020: Charged by complaint with one count of theft of government funds and one count of postage stamp fraud. [1]
- December 1, 2020: Arrested. [6]
- December 20, 2021: Pleaded guilty to mail fraud. [2]
- September 13, 2022: Sentenced to 3 months in prison and 3 years of supervised release, with restitution to be determined at a later date. [7]
- October 19, 2022: Ordered to pay $3,500,000 in restitution, in an amended judgment that left the prison term and the supervised release as they were. [7]

## What the sources leave open

- The newest sources are the court's dockets as CourtListener holds them. Two fit this case, United States v. Koch, Nos. 2:21-cr-00930 and 2:21-cr-00931: both were opened in the District of New Jersey on December 20, 2021, the day the two men pleaded guilty to separate informations. CourtListener's copy of each gives the text of every entry it lists. The first's own entries name Jack Koch and the second's name Steven Koch, apart from a few letters and orders that name no one, and each carries the entries of the complaint's case, Mag. No. 20-9426, which name both men. A search of CourtListener's New Jersey dockets under the name on November 11, 2026 found no other criminal case opened from November 2020 through 2022.
- Each docket gives its man's sentence in its own entries: the sentencing of September 13, 2022, the judgment entered two days later, and an amended judgment of October 19, 2022 that set the restitution the first judgment had left to be determined. The two give the same terms. Searches on November 11, 2026 found no release of the sentences.
- After the amended judgment, the entries in Jack Koch's case, to October 14, 2025, are requests to travel while he was under supervision and the orders on them. Steven Koch's docket lists one entry after his: the judge's order of December 3, 2025 on a probation report, that no formal action be taken and his supervision expire as scheduled.
- The complaint put USPS's loss at $6 million or more; the plea release puts it at about $3 million for the same months, January to September 2020. Neither says why the figure changed.
- The restitution in each amended judgment, $3,500,000, is more than the about $3 million the plea release gives as the loss. The dockets' entries don't say how it was worked out, or whether the two men owe one sum together or each owes it.
- The complaint alleges the scheme ran from January 2018. Steven Koch's information and the plea release cover January to September 2020.
- The 2020 release spells the second defendant both Steven and Stephen Koch. The complaint, his information and the 2021 release say Steven.
- Each man's information leaves its case number blank, Criminal No. 21-, so neither says which of the two cases is whose: each docket's entries do, by naming him. The dockets date each information to December 20, 2021.
- The archived copy of Steven Koch's information skips its third page, most of ¶ 4 on how the scheme worked. Jack Koch's information has that page, and where both copies have text they read the same but for the man's name and town.
- The complaint is a scanned PDF, and the text postalref holds of it is OCR. Every quote from it was read against the page images on November 8, 2026, and those on pages 6 to 8 again on November 11. The OCR misreads some words outside the quotes and the two label images on page 7, and it breaks the first lines of ¶ 17 and ¶ 18, so the quote for the warehouse search leaves out its date, on or about September 22, 2020, and the quote for the interview leaves out that it took place during the search.
- Left out under postalref's rule for naming people: a Fresh N Clear employee the complaint says altered labels at the defendants' direction, who wasn't charged.
- The scheme's start and end follow Steven Koch's information, the document he pleaded under, over the complaint, whose earlier start stays in the timeline.

## Sources

1. [DOJ NJ: Two New Jersey Men Charged with Theft of $6 Million in Postage for Online E-Commerce Business](https://www.justice.gov/usao-nj/pr/two-new-jersey-men-charged-theft-6-million-postage-online-e-commerce-business)
2. [DOJ NJ: Owners of Bergen County Company Admit $3 Million Mail Fraud Scheme](https://www.justice.gov/usao-nj/pr/owners-bergen-county-company-admit-3-million-mail-fraud-scheme)
3. [Criminal Complaint, United States v. Koch, Mag. No. 20-9426 (D.N.J. Nov. 23, 2020)](https://web.archive.org/web/20240704071539id_/https://www.justice.gov/d9/press-releases/attachments/2020/12/01/koch.complaint_0.pdf)
4. [Information, United States v. Jack Koch (D.N.J. Dec. 20, 2021)](https://www.justice.gov/d9/press-releases/attachments/2021/12/20/jkoch.information_0.pdf)
5. [Information, United States v. Steven Koch (D.N.J. Dec. 20, 2021)](https://web.archive.org/web/20240704004533id_/https://www.justice.gov/d9/press-releases/attachments/2021/12/20/skoch.information_0.pdf)
6. [CourtListener docket: United States v. Koch, No. 2:21-cr-00930 (D.N.J.)](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/61632032/united-states-v-koch/)
7. [CourtListener docket: United States v. Koch, No. 2:21-cr-00931 (D.N.J.)](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/61632474/united-states-v-koch/)

---

Unofficial. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the United States Postal Service. This is https://postalref.com/cases/koch-nj as Markdown.
