# United States v. Nguyen

Cuong H. Nguyen, who ran businesses in San Diego that shipped beverages and food products, mostly through Click-N-Ship, put false weight, size, destination and origin on the labels. USPS delivered about 162,221 such packages from 2015 to 2019, about $5.1 million short in postage. [1]

- Scheme: Tampered meters
- Docket: No. 3:21-cr-01131-BAS (S.D. Cal.)
- Investigated by: The U.S. Postal Inspection Service, IRS Criminal Investigation and the Financial Investigations and Border Crimes Task Force
- Newest source: November 4, 2021

## The scheme

A postage evidencing system lets a mailer buy postage labels and put them on packages before mailing them. The releases also call these systems postage meters. [2] Nguyen shipped mostly through Click-N-Ship, one such system, sending beverages and food products from his businesses in San Diego. [2] By computer, he altered, counterfeited, forged and tampered with several of these systems. [1] He put false details on the packages' labels, among them weight, size, destination and origin, which kept USPS from seeing that the postage was too little. [1] USPS took the packages and delivered them, about 162,221 of them from 2015 to 2019, though their labels paid much less than they owed. [1]

## Amounts

- Postage lost: $5,127,712.88, postage underpaid to USPS. [2]
- How many: approximately 162,221, packages delivered with underpaid postage, 2015 to 2019. [1]
- Worked out: $31.61, postage underpaid per package, on average. $5,127,712.88 divided by 162,221 packages, rounded to the cent. The package count is approximate, so the average is too.
- Forfeiture: $862,374.00, forfeiture of the scheme's net profits. [2]
- Assessment: $100.00, the court's special assessment. [3]

## Where it stands

Sentenced to three years of probation, as of the judgment of November 4, 2021. [3]

### United States v. Cuong H. Nguyen

Owned businesses in San Diego that sent packages of beverages and food products. [1]

- Charged: criminal conspiracy, count 1 [3]
- April 13, 2021: Pleaded guilty to conspiring to counterfeit, forge and tamper with postage. [1]
- November 1, 2021: Sentenced to three years of probation, with forfeiture of $862,374. [2]

## What the sources leave open

- The releases name the defendant Cuong H. Nguyen and in places call him Cuong. The court's judgment lists him as Nguyen Cuong.
- The releases write the case number 21-CR-1131-BAS and the judgment's caption 21-CR-01131-BAS.
- The releases say Nguyen shipped from his businesses in San Diego but don't name them, and no business was charged, so none is listed.
- The releases say others altered the labels with Nguyen. They name no one else and report no other charges.
- The plea release calls the underpayment approximately $5,127,712.88. The sentencing release states the same figure without approximately.
- The judgment orders no restitution: its restitution condition is left unchecked, and neither release mentions any. It orders no fine. It includes the forfeiture order filed November 1, 2021 but doesn't state its figure. The $862,374 comes from the releases.
- Nguyen was charged by an information, not an indictment. The information and the plea agreement aren't in the sources: no CourtListener docket for the case turned up, and GovInfo holds only the judgment, which is where its copy comes from.
- The plea release set sentencing for July 12, 2021. It took place on November 1, 2021.
- The releases give the charge's maximum as five years in prison, forfeiture and a $250,000 fine. A maximum isn't a figure of the case, so it isn't among the amounts.
- No tie to NMATS. The releases gloss the postage evidencing systems as postage meters, but the only one they name is Click-N-Ship, which Publication 199 counts as an internal USPS system, apart from postage meters and PC Postage vendors. NMATS tracks the installation and settings of the systems PES providers report, and the scheme as described put false weights, sizes, destinations and origins on labels, which a meter's installation and settings wouldn't show. The releases don't name the other systems he used.
- The case list files the scheme as meter tampering, from the releases' words. What they describe, false weights and other details on the labels, is what the page for United States v. Matheny files as altered postage.

## Sources

1. [DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme](https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdca/pr/online-vendor-pleads-guilty-5-million-postage-fraud-scheme)
2. [DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Sentenced in $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme](https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdca/pr/online-vendor-sentenced-5-million-postage-fraud-scheme)
3. [Judgment, United States v. Nguyen, No. 3:21-cr-01131-BAS (S.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2021), ECF 24](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-casd-3_21-cr-01131/pdf/USCOURTS-casd-3_21-cr-01131-0.pdf)

---

Unofficial. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the United States Postal Service. This is https://postalref.com/cases/nguyen-sdca as Markdown.
