# United States v. Smith

Casey Tyler Smith, who worked at a Wilmington, North Carolina, law firm, printed thousands of dollars of postage on its meter account, then claimed refunds on it at a post office as lost or stolen. The 113 false claims Smith caused to be filed were paid in money orders he and others cashed, and cost the firm more than $80,000. [1]

- Scheme: Refunds
- Court: E.D.N.C.
- Investigated by: The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
- Newest source: June 25, 2020

## The scheme

The charging document says Smith's job at the law firm gave him access to the firm's Pitney Bowes postage meter. [1] He printed thousands of dollars of postage on the meter, charged to the firm's postage account. [1] He and others took the postage to a post office, where Smith filed false refund claims saying it had been lost or stolen. [1] The postage was used to get money for Smith. [1] The post office paid the refunds in USPS money orders, some in Smith's name and some in other people's. [1] Smith and others then took the money orders to banks to cash them. [1]

- Casey Tyler Smith and postal money orders: The charging document says Smith and others took the money orders to banks to cash them. [1]

## Amounts

- Lost by the law firm: more than $80,000, lost by the law firm on whose meter account the postage was printed. [1]
- How many: 113, false refund claims filed at a post office. [1]
- Worked out: more than $707, the average loss per refund claim. $80,000 divided by the 113 claims is $707.96. The loss was more than $80,000, so the average was more than $707.

## Where it stands

Pleaded guilty, as of the release of June 25, 2020. No later source that names him turned up, so the sentence isn't known. [1]

### United States v. Casey Tyler Smith

An employee of a law firm in Wilmington, North Carolina. [1]

- Charged: conspiracy to defraud the United States on claims [1]
- June 25, 2020: Pleaded guilty to conspiring to defraud the United States through false claims, and a federal judge accepted the plea. [1]

## What the sources leave open

- The only release is the plea's, of June 25, 2020. No later release turned up: justice.gov's crawl of November 7, 2026 put no other release under this case, and web searches found none.
- CourtListener has a docket that may be this case: United States v. Smith, No. 7:19-cr-00193 (E.D.N.C.), at https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/16615035/united-states-v-smith/. It was opened on December 19, 2019, and its first entry, of December 20, is an information. On June 24, 2020, the day before the release, it has a plea entered at arraignment, a waiver of indictment and a plea agreement. It has a sentencing on May 27, 2021 and a judgment on June 1, 2021. The docket gives no first name and CourtListener holds none of its documents, so postalref doesn't tie it to Casey Tyler Smith, and his standing stays at the plea. The docket also calls the information "Information - ALL Misdemeanor", though the release's charge carries up to 10 years. The judgment, ECF 25, would settle both and give the sentence.
- The release counts the loss, more than $80,000, against the law firm on whose meter account the postage was printed, not against USPS.
- The release names the crime, conspiracy to defraud the United States on claims, and prints no section of the U.S. Code, so the charge has no statute.
- The release gives the law's maximum: up to 10 years in prison and 3 years of supervised release. A maximum isn't a figure of the case, so it isn't among the amounts.
- The release says others went with Smith to the post office and the banks, and some money orders were made out to others. It names none of them, so they're left out.
- The law firm is the victim, so postalref leaves out the initials the information gives it.

## Sources

1. [DOJ EDNC: Fayetteville Man Pleads Guilty to Stealing Postage from Law Firm to File Fraudulent Claims](https://www.justice.gov/usao-ednc/pr/fayetteville-man-pleads-guilty-stealing-postage-law-firm-file-fraudulent-claims)

---

Unofficial. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the United States Postal Service. This is https://postalref.com/cases/smith-fayetteville as Markdown.
