# United States v. Spiegel

Susan Spiegel, former owner of Postal Connections, a Houston mail drop, bought real postage through the company's Stamps.com account, copied it and put the copies on outgoing mail, which USPS delivered, a loss to USPS of more than $39,000. The oldest copy investigators found was of a stamp first printed in 2009. [2]

- Scheme: Counterfeit stamps
- Court: S.D. Tex.
- Investigated by: The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
- Newest source: August 30, 2013

## The scheme

PC Postage, also called online postage, makes a stamp that carries a meter number assigned to the one account that bought it. [1] Each stamp also has a barcode, and when postal equipment scans it, the scan records data that belongs to that one stamp. [1] Susan Spiegel bought real postage through the company's Stamps.com account, made copies of it and put the copies on outgoing mail, and USPS delivered that mail. [2] The indictment accused both defendants of charging the mail drop's customers for the copied postage. [1]

- Susan Spiegel and Postal Connections: Susan Spiegel ran Postal Connections day to day, including its online stamp purchases. [2]
- Postal Connections and Stamps.com account: Postal Connections bought real postage from Stamps.com, and over time it bought far less. [2]

## How it came to light

The investigation began when barcode data turned up that had allegedly been duplicated, a strong sign of copied postage. The release doesn't say who found it. [1]

- Investigators allegedly tied the duplicated stamps to the meter number assigned to the defendants. [1]
- Investigators examined nearly 2,000 pieces of outgoing mail and found that Susan Spiegel had copied postage she bought and put the copies on mail. [2]
- Investigators seized used and reused sheets of online stamps and more than 1,000 single counterfeit stamps of different values from the business. [2]
- Investigators found that, over time, Postal Connections bought far less real postage from Stamps.com. [2]

## Amounts

- Postage lost: approximately $39,256.92, the loss to USPS the charge release gives for the alleged conspiracy, over about two years. [1]
- Postage lost: more than $39,000, the loss to USPS Susan Spiegel admitted when she pleaded guilty. [2]
- Forfeiture sought: $39,256.92, the forfeiture money judgment for USPS's losses that Susan Spiegel faced at sentencing. [2]
- How many: nearly 2000, pieces of outgoing mail investigators examined. [2]
- How many: more than 1,000, single counterfeit stamps seized from the business, besides sheets of online stamps. [2]

## Where it stands

Susan Spiegel had pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud, as of the release of August 30, 2013. [2]

### United States v. Susan Spiegel

The former owner of Postal Connections. [2]

- Charged: conspiracy to commit mail fraud, one count, against both defendants together [1]
- Charged: mail fraud, five counts, against both defendants together [1]
- Charged: possession of counterfeit postage, 10 counts, against both defendants together [1]
- December 18, 2012: Indicted. [1]
- August 30, 2013: Pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud. [2]

## What the sources leave open

- The indictment charged a second defendant with Susan Spiegel, and the charge release gives the counts for the two together without saying which counts name which defendant. The plea release doesn't mention the second defendant, and postalref found no record of what became of those charges, so that defendant isn't named here.
- Both releases say the postage was copied and the copies mailed, and the plea release calls them counterfeit postage stamps, so the scheme is counterfeit stamps. The plea release says used and re-used sheets of online stamps were seized, but neither release says any stamp went on mail twice.
- Neither release prints a section of the U.S. Code, so the charges have no statutes. The counts are given in the charge release's words.
- The plea release of August 30, 2013 says Susan Spiegel has pleaded guilty without giving the day, so her plea is dated by the release.
- Sentencing was set for September 23, 2013. No later release turned up: justice.gov's releases API has only the plea release for this case, and the Southern District of Texas's archived release indexes for September through December 2013 have none about it. No CourtListener docket was found, and the releases give no case number. Susan Spiegel's standing stays at pleaded.
- The plea release calls the business Postal Connections of America and the charge release Postal Connections. This page uses Postal Connections.
- The forfeiture money judgment of $39,256.92 is one Susan Spiegel faced as of the plea release, not one a source says was ordered.
- No USPS system is listed. The copied stamps carried the meter number of a PC Postage account, but no postage meter was used, and the releases don't name the system that held the account or the one that took the barcode scans that set off the investigation.
- The charge release doesn't say who found the duplicated barcode data that set off the investigation. It says a stamp's barcode data is captured when postal equipment scans it, so the case came to light from the Postal Service's own data.

## Sources

1. [DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage](https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/txs/1News/Releases/2012%20December/121220%20-%20Spiegel.html)
2. [DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage](https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdtx/pr/owner-mail-drop-convicted-manufacturing-and-selling-counterfeit-postage)

---

Unofficial. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the United States Postal Service. This is https://postalref.com/cases/spiegel-mail-drop as Markdown.
