postalref
Cases

United States v. Chen

Lijuan “Angela” Chen managed the warehouses of a City of Industry, California, business that put counterfeit PC Postage labels on over 34 million parcels from China between January 2020 and May 2023, costing USPS over $150 million. The top layer of a large box often held mostly altered labels, which Chen believed likelier than copies to pass a USPS check.

  • Counterfeit labels
  • United States v. Chen, No. 2:23-cr-00302 (C.D. Cal.)
  • 7 sources
  • Newest source: October 30, 2026
Who they were
A shipper of other sellers’ parcels
It ran
November 2019 to May 2023, 42 months
Postage lost
Over $150 million
Investigated by
The U.S. Postal Inspection Service and IRS Criminal Investigation
Where it stands
Chen was sentenced to 30 months in prison and three years of supervised release and ordered to pay $158,288,991 in restitution, and a notice of appeal followed.

The scheme

Counterfeit labels

A PC Postage label carries an information-based indicia, or IBI: a coded block, signed digitally, that shows whether the mailer paid the right postage for the piece's class of mail. To avoid paying postage, Hu began by printing duplicate and counterfeit Netstamps, stamps sold online by vendors and printed on adhesive paper, the plea agreement says. Hu and others began building a computer program that made counterfeit PC Postage shipping labels, the plea agreement says.

For a duplicated label, the IBI from a label bought for an earlier mailing was copied onto a made-up label built to look like a PC Postage vendor's, so no postage was paid for the new parcel. Customers put a barcode from a web portal on each package and air-mailed it to the warehouse Chen managed. Chen and workers she directed scanned each barcode into the portal to get the counterfeit label made for that package. Parcels went to USPS in large boxes called gaylords. To get them accepted at USPS plants, the plea agreement says, Chen and Hu often arranged a gaylord so that its top layer, the parcels anyone looking in would see, was mostly altered labels rather than duplicated ones, believing altered labels likelier to pass a USPS inspection.

When USPS turned a load away, it went back to the warehouse, got new labels and was split into smaller loads to try again, the complaint says. Many labels dated 2023 carried the meter numbers of postage meters taken out of use in 2020, the complaint says. On other labels the two barcodes disagreed: the tracking number named Pitney Bowes as the postage vendor while the IBI named EasyPost.

On November 20, 2019, Stamps.com told USPIS that one Endicia account had printed several million Zero Postage Labels: blank labels with a valid tracking number and no postage paid.

Altered postage

For an altered label, Hu bought a real PC Postage label from a vendor, giving a false weight and shipping distance, the plea agreement says. Then the printed part of the label was changed to match the parcel's real weight and distance. At least one parcel in ten in each gaylord carried an altered label.

The sources tie together , and (figure 1).

  • Lijuan “Angela” Chen and Package shipping business in City of Industry, California

    Chen admitted that she and Hu owned and ran the business.

  • Chuanhua “Hugh” Hu and Package shipping business in City of Industry, California

    Chen's plea agreement says Hu owned and ran the business with her. Against Hu it is an allegation.

  • Chuanhua “Hugh” Hu and Lijuan “Angela” Chen

    Hu is Chen's husband, the complaint says.

The control it beat

A label is only as good as the payment behind it. When nothing is wrong, a shipper pays an approved provider, the provider pays the Postal Service, and only then does the provider’s software print the label (figure 2). A counterfeit label skips the middle of that, and a real one changed after it was printed gets around it: either way the label looks paid for, and its postage wasn’t.

12345registers, agrees to USPS’s termspays for postage, by ACH or credit cardpays USPS on the shipper’s behalfits software prints the label, with an indiciumthe package, with the label on itEasyPost, Endicia, Pitney Bowes or Stamps.comThe shipperAn approved providerUSPSThe shipperAn approved providerUSPS

Figure 2. How a label is paid for when nothing is wrong.

From DMM 604, Postage Payment Methods and Refunds, 4.1.1, 4.1.4, 4.2.1; 39 CFR Part 501, Postage Evidencing Systems, § 501.1(c), (d); § 501.16(a), (b)

So the Postal Service looks for it twice: a package is sampled as it enters a plant and checked again on the sorting equipment. One that both miss is delivered (figure 3).

Entering a mail processing plantEntering a mail processing plantsampled there since April 2025Counterfeit postage found, sampledOn mail sorting equipmentOn mail sorting equipmentthe Intercept Process, since fiscal year 2023Counterfeit postage found, interceptedmissedAt its final delivery pointAt its final delivery pointnot caughtendCounterfeit postage foundCounterfeit postage foundAbandonedAbandoneddisposed of at USPS’s discretionend

Figure 3. Where the Postal Service looks for a label that wasn’t paid for.

From USPS OIG, Counterfeit Postage Program, 25-072-R26, September 2026, pp.6, 7 and 13; DMM 604, Postage Payment Methods and Refunds, 8.4.2

How it came to light

In late 2018 and early 2019 the Postal Service told postal inspectors that many parcels thought to carry counterfeit postage were entering the mail around Los Angeles.

  1. From June to November 2019 postal inspectors reviewed mail at Los Angeles-area postal facilities and, the complaint says, kept seeing thousands of parcels with counterfeit postage shipped by businesses linked to Hu.

  2. Postal inspectors questioned Hu on November 20 and again on November 21, 2019, about what the complaint calls his use of counterfeit postage.

  3. After Hu left the country, the complaint says, the mailings tied to him seemed to stop for four or five days. From about November 27, 2019, Postal Service staff and postal inspectors saw large loads of parcels with counterfeit postage arriving at the Los Angeles processing plant.

  4. Postal inspectors visited a warehouse they had identified as bringing in parcels with counterfeit postage. Its owner told them Chen had asked him to ship the parcels.

  5. On several occasions in 2020 postal inspectors saw large loads of parcels with counterfeit postage delivered to the Los Angeles processing plant.

  6. A postal inspector searched California business records and found several companies that list Chen as their agent.

  7. Postal inspectors began watching the City of Industry warehouse and Chen's home.

  8. At the Los Angeles processing plant, investigators sampled a truckload of parcels and found most of them carried counterfeit postage.

  9. After watching the warehouse, a postal inspector followed a truck to the Los Angeles plant and sampled its boxes. Each held several parcels with counterfeit postage.

  10. Postal inspectors recorded a call the warehouse owner placed to Chen. She told him the police had been to her place before and to tell the authorities he knew nothing.

  11. IRS Criminal Investigation reviewed bank accounts under Hu's and Chen's control and, the complaint says, found they received substantial amounts from businesses believed to be in Hong Kong and China.

  12. A postal inspector and an IRS agent met two informants who said they had worked at the warehouse. Both named Chen as the person in charge.

  13. A USPS revenue fraud analyst picked out red flags on the parcels found with counterfeit postage, such as discontinued Endicia meters, and searched USPS databases for every parcel through the Los Angeles plants that had them.

  14. Law enforcement seized funds from Chen's bank accounts.

Figure 4 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands. A date in the list above pins its bar.

Ran 42 monthsRan 42 months42 months to a charge42 months to a chargeNoticedNoticedToldToldHid itHid itMail examinedMail examinedInterviewInterviewMail examinedMail examinedMail examinedMail examinedInterviewInterviewRecordsRecordsSurveillanceSurveillanceMail examinedMail examinedMail examinedMail examined2 charged2 charged1 arrested1 arrested1 pleaded guilty1 pleaded guilty1 wanted1 wanted1 sentenced1 sentenced20182020202220242026

Figure 4. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.

What the filings say they knew

Told of the problem. On November 19, 2019, postal inspectors gave Hu a voluntary discontinuance, their written notice about mail with invalid postage, the complaint says.

“VD issued on November 19, 2019, to recipient HU.”

Complaint, pages 1, 4, 12 to 21, 23 to 25, 27 and 29, United States v. Chen, No. 2:23-mj-02644 (C.D. Cal. May 22, 2023), ECF 1, Page 19 · Affidavit, ¶ 36(a)Open the source

Acted to hide it. When USPS plants in Southern California began rejecting more of the parcels in May 2020, Chen and Hu sent parcels to warehouse owners in Ohio and Texas to avoid detection, the plea agreement says.

“In May 2020, packages mailed by defendant and co-defendant Hu began to be rejected with greater frequency by USPS distribution centers in Southern California. To avoid detection by USPS, defendant and co-defendant Hu began shipping packages bearing counterfeit PC postage shipping labels to other warehouse owners in Ohio and Texas.”

Plea Agreement, pages 13 and 28 to 33, United States v. Chen, No. 2:23-cr-00302 (C.D. Cal. Apr. 7, 2024), ECF 43, Page 31 · Attachment A, ¶ 8(g)Open the source

Acted to hide it. When postal inspectors confronted one of those warehouse owners and he called Chen, she told him not to worry and to say falsely that he got the packages from China and didn't know the postage was counterfeit, the plea agreement says.

“When one of these warehouse owners was subsequently confronted by USPIS postal inspectors and contacted defendant, defendant advised the warehouse owner not to worry and instructed him to falsely claim that he received the packages from China and that he did not know the subject packages bore counterfeit postage.”

Plea Agreement, pages 13 and 28 to 33, United States v. Chen, No. 2:23-cr-00302 (C.D. Cal. Apr. 7, 2024), ECF 43, Page 31 · Attachment A, ¶ 8(g)Open the source

Told of the problem. Postal inspectors gave voluntary discontinuances to people tied to Chen's companies who tried to mail parcels with counterfeit postage labels, the complaint says.

“In reviewing USPIS records, I found the following VD’s were issued to individuals associated with CHEN’s companies, who attempted to introduce mail bearing counterfeit postage labels into the mail stream.”

Complaint, pages 1, 4, 12 to 21, 23 to 25, 27 and 29, United States v. Chen, No. 2:23-mj-02644 (C.D. Cal. May 22, 2023), ECF 1, Page 19 · Affidavit, ¶ 36Open the source

What it cost

Over $60 millionPostage lostEstimated USPS revenue lost from November 1, 2022, to April 30, 2023, as the complaint put it.
Over $150 millionPostage lostUSPS losses from January 2020 to May 2023, as Chen admitted in her plea agreement.
About $4.41Worked outAverage loss to USPS per parcel, January 2020 to May 2023. $150 million divided by 34 million parcels. Both figures are floors the plea agreement gives as "over", so this is a rough average, not a stated figure.
Over 9 millionHow manyParcels with counterfeit postage from November 1, 2022, to April 30, 2023, as the complaint estimated.
Over 34 millionHow manyParcels mailed with counterfeit PC Postage labels from January 2020 to May 2023.
Approximately 4,779 packagesHow manyParcels in one delivery to USPS on October 25, 2022.
Over 17,000How manyCounterfeit First-Class Mail labels printed at the warehouse on May 23, 2023.

Where it stands

Chen was sentenced to 30 months in prison and three years of supervised release and ordered to pay $158,288,991 in restitution, and a notice of appeal followed, as of the docket of October 30, 2026. Hu stands charged and is believed to be in China, as of the release of April 26, 2024.

United States v. Lijuan “Angela” Chen

Stayed in the United States and managed the warehouses the business shipped from.

Charge
Conspiracy to defraud the United States, count 1 
Forging and counterfeiting postage stamps, aiding and abetting, count 5 
DateProceeding
May 22, 2023Charged by criminal complaint with conspiracy to defraud the United States and with possessing and using counterfeit postage.
May 24, 2023Arrested.
June 21, 2023Indicted with Hu on counts 1 to 5.
April 26, 2024Pleaded guilty to counts 1 and 5 of the indictment, and the court accepted the plea.
July 9, 2026Sentenced to 30 months in prison on each of counts 1 and 5, served at the same time.

United States v. Chuanhua “Hugh” Hu

Chen's husband and co-defendant. The complaint says he ran the shipping business before her and left for China two days after postal inspectors interviewed him in November 2019.

Charge
Conspiracy to defraud the United States, count 1 
Passing and possessing counterfeit obligations of the United States, counts 2-4 
Forging and counterfeiting postage stamps, count 5 
DateProceeding
June 21, 2023Indicted with Chen on counts 1 to 5.
April 26, 2024Charged with conspiracy to defraud the United States, passing and possessing counterfeit obligations of the United States, and forging and counterfeiting postage stamps, and believed to be a fugitive living in China.

What was ordered, agreed or paid

$158,288,991RestitutionRestitution to USPS, against Lijuan “Angela” Chen.

More cases of counterfeit labels