postalref

Cases

Public cases of postage fraud, each told from its court filings and the agencies’ own releases: how the scheme worked, how it came to light and what proved it. 24 cases are written, of the 90 on the list.

Counterfeit labels

A shipping label made to look paid for, with no postage bought behind it.

Altered postage

A paid label or stamp changed afterwards to cover more than was paid.

Short-paid postage

Mail sent with less postage than its weight, size or class owes.

Counterfeit stamps

Copies of stamps, sold or stuck on mail in place of real ones.

Counterfeit meter postage

A meter’s imprint printed by something that paid the Postal Service nothing.

Tampered meters

A real postage meter changed so it prints postage nobody paid for.

Permit and bulk mail

Bulk mailings entered on a permit or a postage statement without the postage being paid.

Unearned discounts

A discount rate claimed for mail that didn’t meet its rules.

Refunds

Refunds claimed for postage that was used, or was never lost.

Bad checks

Stamps and postage bought with checks that don’t clear.

What the cases have in common

Most of these schemes ran for years before anyone acted. Of the 17 cases whose records date both the start and the first action (a charge, an arrest, a plea, a conviction or a settlement), the middle one ran 64 months first. Figure 1 draws each to scale; press a bar for its case.

ZhangZhangChenChenLabelsBank.comLabelsBank.comPasicPasicKochKochPlexus Worldwide, LLCPlexus Worldwide, LLCPadgett et al.Padgett et al.FisterFisterLimLimMathenyMathenyNguyenNguyenGargano, Patel and LakkamsaniGargano, Patel and LakkamsaniKaczorowskiKaczorowskiCaudilloCaudilloKussKussMJH Healthcare HoldingsMJH Healthcare HoldingsSotoSoto20052010201520202025

Press a bar for what the sources say of its case.

Figure 1. From each scheme’s start to the first action a source dates.

They came to light in a few ways: the Postal Service's own review, sampling or data found it in 4 (Chen, Lim, Plexus Worldwide, LLC and Spiegel); a postal employee noticed it in 2 (Padgett et al. and Matheny); and someone inside the business reported it, or sued over it in one (MJH Healthcare Holdings).

To prove them, the investigators searched a place or seized property in 8 (Padgett et al., Caudillo, Chen and 5 more); examined the mail or parcels themselves in 7 (Padgett et al., Chen, Fister and 4 more); reviewed postal, business, bank or marketplace records in 7 (Padgett et al., Chen, Koch and 4 more); questioned the party or a witness in 5 (Padgett et al., Chen, Koch and 2 more); bought from the party undercover in one (Padgett et al.); and watched or recorded the party in one (Chen).

What the sources say showed they knew: was told of the problem in 5 (Padgett et al., Chen, Kaczorowski and 2 more); said so, in their own words in 4 (Koch, LabelsBank.com, Matheny and Zhang); acted to hide it in 3 (Chen, LabelsBank.com and Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani); and a court found their conduct showed it in one (Matheny).