Cases
Public cases of postage fraud, each told from its court filings and the agencies’ own releases: how the scheme worked, how it came to light and what proved it. 24 cases are written, of the 90 on the list.
Counterfeit labels
A shipping label made to look paid for, with no postage bought behind it.
- United States v. ChenLijuan “Angela” Chen managed the warehouses of a City of Industry, California, business that put counterfeit PC Postage labels on over 34 million parcels from China between January 2020 and May 2023, costing USPS over $150 million. The top layer of a large box often held mostly altered labels, which Chen believed likelier than copies to pass a USPS check.No. 2:23-cr-00302 (C.D. Cal.) · 2019 to 2023
- LabelsBank.comThe indictment alleges that from about August 2023 Faheem Akram ran LabelsBank.com, a website USPS had not authorized, which sold counterfeit postage labels, usually for $2 each whatever the package's service, weight, size or destination: over 5.1 million labels, costing USPS about $126 million in revenue.No. 0:26-cr-60249 (S.D. Fla.) · from 2023
- United States v. ZhangXiaodong Zhang, of Cheswick, Pennsylvania, mailed five parcels marked First Class from April 25 to 29, 2016 to carry out a scheme to defraud USPS, and stole more than $1,000 in postage in those days. The indictment alleges Zhang sold phone accessories from his home and falsified his postage labels.No. 2:20-cr-00311 (W.D. Pa.) · 2015 to 2016
Altered postage
A paid label or stamp changed afterwards to cover more than was paid.
- United States v. KochJack and Steven Koch, co-owners of Fresh N Clear, which sold household goods online, bought Priority Mail Flat Rate Envelope labels, electronically removed the line marking them Flat Rate, and put them on boxes that didn't qualify, keeping about $3 million in postage from USPS from January to September 2020.No. 2:21-cr-00930 (D.N.J.) · 2020
- United States v. PasicJack Zeljko Pasic, who ran Diavega, an eBay seller, printed postage on a meter and altered the labels to hide that he had paid one cent, shipping over 9,000 packages from April 2009 to October 2010 and leaving more than $18,000 unpaid. Packages USPS tried to return for postage due still reached buyers.No. 3:15-cr-02381-CAB · 2009 to 2010
Short-paid postage
Mail sent with less postage than its weight, size or class owes.
- AtLast Holdings and NewgisticsThe United States alleged that AtLast Holdings, a mailing and logistics provider, reported the packages it shipped through USPS as smaller and lighter than they were, and so paid less postage than it owed.
- Plexus Worldwide, LLCThe United States alleged that Plexus Worldwide, a health products seller, mailed packages between January 2015 and January 2016 with postage figured from details that didn't belong to the items, or with reused postage, so they showed as paid when they weren't. The United States said more than 40% of the pieces reviewed were short-paid.(D. Ariz.) · 2013 to 2016
Counterfeit stamps
Copies of stamps, sold or stuck on mail in place of real ones.
- United States v. Padgett et al.The indictment alleges that from about January 2024 John Patrick Best and Kevin Douglas Padgett bought counterfeit stamps from suppliers in China and resold them online as genuine U.S. flag Forever stamps, which Padgett mailed from post offices in Alabama, and that the scheme took in at least $1.7 million.(M.D. Ala.) · from 2024
- United States v. FisterWayne Fister, of San Diego, bought counterfeit U.S. postage stamps from a seller in China at about 10 percent of the price of genuine stamps and, from about July 2024, sold them as genuine through a seller account on an online marketplace, receiving $6,068,929.No. 3:26-cr-00723 (S.D. Cal.) · from 2024
- United States v. SpiegelSusan Spiegel, former owner of Postal Connections, a Houston mail drop, bought real postage through the company's Stamps.com account, copied it and put the copies on outgoing mail, which USPS delivered, a loss to USPS of more than $39,000. The oldest copy investigators found was of a stamp first printed in 2009.(S.D. Tex.)
Counterfeit meter postage
A meter’s imprint printed by something that paid the Postal Service nothing.
- United States v. ClarkJames H. Clark, Jr., of Las Cruces, New Mexico, who owned and ran a business selling books through websites, copied postage meter stamps he had bought from stamps.com and on October 19, 2010, held 1,527 copies showing $9,142.98 in postage, meant for mailing packages through USPS. USPS's loss came to $365,827.(D.N.M.)
- United States v. LimNeal Lim, who owned mail presort companies in the Houston area, and four people who worked for him printed counterfeit postage on customers' mass mailings with altered postage meters, kept the postage the customers paid and claimed presort refunds on that mail. USPS lost more than $14 million from January 2004 to July 2007.(S.D. Tex.) · 2004 to 2007
- United States v. MathenyFrom 2013 to 2017 Bradley Jon Matheny, an eBay seller in Marion, Iowa, covered the bottom half of refunded Priority labels with First-Class barcodes and changed the weight on other labels, dropping the packages at the post office dock late in the evening. An expert put USPS's shortfall above $250,000.No. 20-CR-50 (N.D. Iowa) · 2013 to 2017
Tampered meters
A real postage meter changed so it prints postage nobody paid for.
Permit and bulk mail
Bulk mailings entered on a permit or a postage statement without the postage being paid.
- United States v. CaudilloSince at least 2012, Juan Enrique Caudillo, a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office, took bribes from business mailers, Premier Mailing's owner among them, to approve their bulk mailings as fully paid when the postage was unpaid or short. Losses to USPS came to more than $11.7 million.No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal.) · from 2012
- United States v. KaczorowskiSteven Kaczorowski, who managed a bulk mailing company, added a digit to the weight of paid mail on drop-shipment clearance forms, and unpaid mail was buried under paid mail on pallets, so the mail looked paid for while customers were billed for the postage. From at least 2010 to September 2017, more than $1.5 million went unpaid.No. 1:19-cr-00213 (D.N.J.) · 2010 to 2017
- United States v. KussRobert Kuss, managing partner of the mail service provider Creative Marketing Group, filled out and stamped PS Form 8125s himself so bulk mailings he brought to destination USPS facilities looked verified and debited at the Bristol, Connecticut, unit when neither had happened. From about July 2014 to March 2016, at least 125 mailings, 3,260,183 pieces, cost USPS $749,573.No. 3:16-cr-00224 (D. Conn.) · 2014 to 2016
- Presort company's president and production manager, indicted by September 2000The indictment alleges that the president and the production manager of a presort company, a business that prepares mail for others to send, defrauded the Postal Service through a series of postage schemes.
- United States v. Gargano, Patel and LakkamsaniThe two owners of Prodigy Mailing Services, an Illinois bulk-mailing company, forged a Postal clerk's signature on Verification Forms from about March 2010 to February 2015 and stamped them with a USPS date stamp, so over 80 million pieces looked paid, a loss to USPS of at least $16 million.No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.) · 2010 to 2015
Unearned discounts
A discount rate claimed for mail that didn’t meet its rules.
- MJH Healthcare HoldingsThe United States alleged that MJH Healthcare Holdings, a publisher for healthcare providers, sent 40 mailings at the periodicals rate from October 2021 to June 2024. That rate needs over half the copies to go to people who requested them, and the United States said MJH counted unqualified names from third-party lists and requests three years old or more.No. 3:22-cv-07367 (D.N.J.) · 2021 to 2024
- Pitney Bowes Presort ServicesThe United States alleged that Pitney Bowes Presort Services, which sorted large mailers' mail and presented it to USPS, claimed discounted postage rates on its customers' mail that didn't meet the Move Update standard, and so underpaid postage.
Refunds
Refunds claimed for postage that was used, or was never lost.
Bad checks
Stamps and postage bought with checks that don’t clear.
- United States v. HinshawRonald Hinshaw, of Lufkin, Texas, paid with 140 bad checks, $126,098 in all, at post offices across Texas. With one of them, at a Fort Worth post office on May 20, 2015, Hinshaw bought 300 booklets of twenty 49-cent stamps, and then sold the stamps below face value.(N.D. Tex.)
- United States v. SotoOver two days in August 2023 William Soto bought more than $30,000 in USPS stamps in twelve purchases at post offices in Oneida, Oswego and Onondaga counties, New York, paying each time with a fraudulent check.(N.D.N.Y.) · 2023
What the cases have in common
Most of these schemes ran for years before anyone acted. Of the 17 cases whose records date both the start and the first action (a charge, an arrest, a plea, a conviction or a settlement), the middle one ran 64 months first. Figure 1 draws each to scale; press a bar for its case.
Press a bar for what the sources say of its case.
They came to light in a few ways: the Postal Service's own review, sampling or data found it in 4 (Chen, Lim, Plexus Worldwide, LLC and Spiegel); a postal employee noticed it in 2 (Padgett et al. and Matheny); and someone inside the business reported it, or sued over it in one (MJH Healthcare Holdings).
To prove them, the investigators searched a place or seized property in 8 (Padgett et al., Caudillo, Chen and 5 more); examined the mail or parcels themselves in 7 (Padgett et al., Chen, Fister and 4 more); reviewed postal, business, bank or marketplace records in 7 (Padgett et al., Chen, Koch and 4 more); questioned the party or a witness in 5 (Padgett et al., Chen, Koch and 2 more); bought from the party undercover in one (Padgett et al.); and watched or recorded the party in one (Chen).
What the sources say showed they knew: was told of the problem in 5 (Padgett et al., Chen, Kaczorowski and 2 more); said so, in their own words in 4 (Koch, LabelsBank.com, Matheny and Zhang); acted to hide it in 3 (Chen, LabelsBank.com and Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani); and a court found their conduct showed it in one (Matheny).