United States v. Nguyen
Cuong H. Nguyen, who ran businesses in San Diego that shipped beverages and food products, mostly through Click-N-Ship, put false weight, size, destination and origin on the labels. USPS delivered about 162,221 such packages from 2015 to 2019, about $5.1 million short in postage.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“Cuong admitted that he misrepresented information appearing on postage labels attached to packages in several ways—including misstating the weight, size, destination, and origin of the packages—that were intended to, and in fact did deceive, the USPS as to the underpayment of postage.”Open the source
- Tampered meters
- United States v. Nguyen, No. 3:21-cr-01131-BAS (S.D. Cal.)
- 3 sources
- Newest source: November 4, 2021
- Who they were
- A seller shipping its own goods
- It ran
- 2015 to 2019, 48 months
- Postage lost
- $5,127,712.88
- Investigated by
- The U.S. Postal Inspection Service, IRS Criminal Investigation and the Financial Investigations and Border Crimes Task Force
- Where it stands
- Sentenced to three years of probation.
The scheme
A postage evidencing system lets a mailer buy postage labels and put them on packages before mailing them. The releases also call these systems postage meters.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Sentenced in $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme““postage evidencing systems”—i.e., postage meters. These postage meters are intended to expedite the delivery and shipment of USPS packages by allowing mailers to purchase and affix postage labels in advance of depositing them into the mail.”Open the source Nguyen shipped mostly through Click-N-Ship, one such system, sending beverages and food products from his businesses in San Diego.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Sentenced in $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“Nguyen primarily used the postage evidencing system known as Click-N-Ship® when sending packages of beverages and food products from his businesses in San Diego.”Open the source By computer, he altered, counterfeited, forged and tampered with several of these systems.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“Cuong digitally altered, counterfeited, forged, and tampered with various “postage evidencing systems”—i.e., postage meters.”Open the source
He put false details on the packages' labels, among them weight, size, destination and origin, which kept USPS from seeing that the postage was too little.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“Cuong admitted that he misrepresented information appearing on postage labels attached to packages in several ways—including misstating the weight, size, destination, and origin of the packages—that were intended to, and in fact did deceive, the USPS as to the underpayment of postage.”Open the source USPS took the packages and delivered them, about 162,221 of them from 2015 to 2019, though their labels paid much less than they owed.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“when the USPS received the packages with labels that Nguyen and others had altered, forged, and counterfeited, they paid much less to the USPS than was owed, but the packages—approximately 162,221 between 2015 and 2019—were delivered anyway.”Open the source
How it came to light
The sources don’t say how the case came to light.
Figure 1 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands.
Figure 1. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.
What it cost
| $5,127,712.88Postage lost | Postage underpaid to USPS.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Sentenced in $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“As a result of the conspiracy, Nguyen underpaid $5,127,712.88 in postage to the USPS”Open the source |
|---|---|
| $31.61Worked out | Postage underpaid per package, on average. $5,127,712.88 divided by 162,221 packages, rounded to the cent. The package count is approximate, so the average is too. |
| Approximately 162,221How many | Packages delivered with underpaid postage, 2015 to 2019.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“but the packages—approximately 162,221 between 2015 and 2019—were delivered anyway.”Open the source |
Where it stands
Sentenced to three years of probation, as of the judgment of November 4, 2021.Judgment, United States v. Nguyen, No. 3:21-cr-01131-BAS (S.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2021), ECF 24Page 2“The defendant is hereby sentenced to probation for a term of: THREE (3) YEARS.”Open the source
United States v. Cuong H. Nguyen
Owned businesses in San Diego that sent packages of beverages and food products.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“Nguyen primarily used the postage evidencing system known as Click-N-Ship® when sending packages of beverages and food products from his businesses in San Diego.”Open the source
| Charge |
|---|
| Criminal conspiracy, count 1 Judgment, United States v. Nguyen, No. 3:21-cr-01131-BAS (S.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2021), ECF 24Page 1 · Information, Count 1“18:371 - CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY”Open the source |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| April 13, 2021 | Pleaded guilty to conspiring to counterfeit, forge and tamper with postage.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Pleads Guilty to $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“Cuong H. Nguyen pleaded guilty in federal court today to conspiring to engage in a wide-ranging postage counterfeiting, forging, and tampering scheme”Open the source |
| November 1, 2021 | Sentenced to three years of probation, with forfeiture of $862,374.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Sentenced in $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“His sentence of 3 years’ probation includes the obligation to forfeit $862,374.00, as profits, proceeds, and property obtained directly or indirectly from the conspiracy.”Open the source |
What was ordered, agreed or paid
| $862,374.00Forfeiture | Forfeiture of the scheme's net profits.DOJ SDCA: Online Vendor Sentenced in $5 Million Postage Fraud Scheme“His sentence of 3 years’ probation includes the obligation to forfeit $862,374.00”Open the source |
|---|