postalref
Cases

Plexus Worldwide, LLC

The United States alleged that Plexus Worldwide, a health products seller, mailed packages between January 2015 and January 2016 with postage figured from details that didn't belong to the items, or with reused postage, so they showed as paid when they weren't. The United States said more than 40% of the pieces reviewed were short-paid.

Who they were
A seller shipping its own goods
It ran
June 2013 to October 2016, 40 months
Investigated by
The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
Where it stands
Settled.

The scheme

Short-paid postage

Short-paid postage means the postage and fees on a piece add up to less than its price and any extra services cost. Plexus admitted it handed USPS mail whose postage was worked out from weights and other details reported too low, so the postage paid was short. The United States claimed that from January 2015 through January 2016 Plexus figured its postage from details that didn't belong to the items it mailed.

The United States claimed the postage on these pieces told USPS it was paid in full when it wasn't, and that this let Plexus underpay or not pay at all. Plexus admitted its systems and controls fell short, which led to payments below the postage it owed. Plexus said errors in other companies' information systems caused both underpayments and overpayments of postage.

Plexus said it tried to fix the problems, but the short-paid and duplicate postage went on after the Postal Inspection Service's letters.

Reused postage

Duplicate postage is postage used again without permission. The piece shows its postage as paid when nothing was paid for it. The United States claimed Plexus also mailed items with reused postage, leaving their postage unpaid. Plexus accepted responsibility for short-paying postage and for duplicate postage that, after its overpayments were counted, left it owing USPS.

How it came to light

The Postal Inspection Service found Plexus packages with short-paid postage and others with duplicate postage, starting in June 2013.

  1. From June 2013 through October 2016, post offices around the country sent the Postal Inspection Service about 125 reports of short-paid and duplicate postage from Plexus.

  2. The United States served a written demand for information about the conduct, Civil Investigation Demand No. 16-03, dated this day, on Plexus Worldwide, Inc.

  3. The United States said that, through a statistical consulting firm, it found more than 40% of the Plexus pieces examined in a review were short-paid.

Figure 1 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands. A date in the list above pins its bar.

Ran 40 monthsRan 40 months121 months to a settlement121 months to a settlementNoticedNoticedToldToldToldToldToldToldMail examinedMail examinedRecordsRecordsSettledSettled20142016201820202022

Figure 1. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.

What showed they knew

Told of the problem. The Postal Inspection Service sent Plexus certified letters about its short-paid postage in June 2013, March 2014 and July 2016, and the letters also pointed out its duplicate postage.

“first in June 2013 and again in March 2014 and July 2016, the USPIS sent Plexus certified letters regarding the fact that it mailed items with shortpaid postage. These letters also pointed out Plexus’ use of duplicate postage.”

Settlement Agreement, United States and Plexus Worldwide, LLC (D. Ariz., effective July 28, 2023), OCR transcription of the scan, Page 2 · Recital D.dOpen the source

Told of the problem. From August 2013 to September 2016, USPS sent Plexus 31 written notices about short-paid postage.

“From August 2013 to September 2016, Plexus received 31 written notices from the USPS regarding shortpaid postage.”

Settlement Agreement, United States and Plexus Worldwide, LLC (D. Ariz., effective July 28, 2023), OCR transcription of the scan, Page 3 · Recital D.fOpen the source

Told of the problem. From November 2014 to June 2016, Plexus's customers, known as its ambassadors, told it more than 30 times about short-paid postage.

“From November 2014 to June 2016, Plexus’ customers, also known as its “ambassadors,” informed Plexus more than 30 times about shortpaid postage.”

Settlement Agreement, United States and Plexus Worldwide, LLC (D. Ariz., effective July 28, 2023), OCR transcription of the scan, Page 3 · Recital D.gOpen the source

What it cost

More than 40%How manyThe share of the Plexus pieces examined in a review that the United States, through a statistical consulting firm, found short-paid.

Where it stands

Settled, as of the release of July 28, 2023.

Plexus Worldwide, LLC

An Arizona company that markets health and wellness products directly.

Claim
The False Claims Act
DateProceeding
July 28, 2023Settled the United States' allegations, admitting it underpaid postage and used duplicate postage that left it owing USPS.

What was ordered, agreed or paid

$600,000.00Settled forWhat Plexus agreed to pay the United States, within 30 days of the agreement taking effect.
$367,223.31Worked outThe part of the $600,000 beyond restitution, which the agreement doesn't name. $600,000.00 minus $232,776.69.
$232,776.69RestitutionThe part of the $600,000 that the agreement counts as restitution, money paid back for what was lost.

More cases of short-paid postage