United States v. Spiegel
Susan Spiegel, former owner of Postal Connections, a Houston mail drop, bought real postage through the company's Stamps.com account, copied it and put the copies on outgoing mail, which USPS delivered, a loss to USPS of more than $39,000. The oldest copy investigators found was of a stamp first printed in 2009.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“investigators determined Spiegel purchased legitimate postage using her company’s Stamps.com account, duplicated it and applied the counterfeit postage to outgoing mail - which was ultimately delivered by the USPS.”Open the source
- Counterfeit stamps
- United States v. Spiegel (S.D. Tex.)
- 2 sources
- Newest source: August 30, 2013
- Who they were
- A mail service provider
- Postage lost
- More than $39,000
- Investigated by
- The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
- Where it stands
- Susan Spiegel had pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud.
The scheme
PC Postage, also called online postage, makes a stamp that carries a meter number assigned to the one account that bought it.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“Online postage, also referred to as Net postage or PC postage, generates a stamp containing a unique meter number assigned to the registered user.”Open the source Each stamp also has a barcode, and when postal equipment scans it, the scan records data that belongs to that one stamp.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“The stamp also contains a barcode which, when scanned by postal equipment, captures data unique to each stamp.”Open the source Susan Spiegel bought real postage through the company's Stamps.com account, made copies of it and put the copies on outgoing mail, and USPS delivered that mail.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“investigators determined Spiegel purchased legitimate postage using her company’s Stamps.com account, duplicated it and applied the counterfeit postage to outgoing mail - which was ultimately delivered by the USPS.”Open the source
The indictment accused both defendants of charging the mail drop's customers for the copied postage.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“are accused of involvement in a conspiracy to illegally duplicate PC postage, causing mail bearing the counterfeit postage to be delivered by the United States Postal Service, charging their customers for the counterfeit postage and possessing counterfeit postage stamps.”Open the source
The sources tie together , and (figure 1).
- Susan Spiegel and Postal Connections
Susan Spiegel ran Postal Connections day to day, including its online stamp purchases.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Spiegel had primary responsibility for the daily operations of the business, to include online stamp purchases.”Open the source
- Postal Connections and Stamps.com account
Postal Connections bought real postage from Stamps.com, and over time it bought far less.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Over time, the investigation revealed a drastic decline in legitimate postage purchased by Postal Connections from Stamps.com.”Open the source
Figure 1. Who and what the scheme tied together. Press a box or a line for what the sources say of it.
How it came to light
The investigation began when barcode data turned up that had allegedly been duplicated, a strong sign of copied postage. The release doesn't say who found it.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“Investigation into the activities of Postal Connections was triggered based upon the discovery of barcode data that had allegedly been duplicated - a strong indicator of the use of possible counterfeit postage.”Open the source
Investigators allegedly tied the duplicated stamps to the meter number assigned to the defendants.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“Further investigation allegedly indicated the duplicated stamps were associated to the meter number assigned to the Spiegel’s.”Open the source
Investigators examined nearly 2,000 pieces of outgoing mail and found that Susan Spiegel had copied postage she bought and put the copies on mail.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“After examining nearly 2000 individual pieces of outgoing mail, investigators determined Spiegel purchased legitimate postage using her company’s Stamps.com account, duplicated it and applied the counterfeit postage to outgoing mail”Open the source
Investigators seized used and reused sheets of online stamps and more than 1,000 single counterfeit stamps of different values from the business.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Used and re-used sheets of online stamps and more than 1,000 individual counterfeit postage stamps of various denominations were seized from Spiegel’s business.”Open the source
Investigators found that, over time, Postal Connections bought far less real postage from Stamps.com.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Over time, the investigation revealed a drastic decline in legitimate postage purchased by Postal Connections from Stamps.com.”Open the source
What it cost
| Approximately $39,256.92Postage lost | The loss to USPS the charge release gives for the alleged conspiracy, over about two years.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“The alleged conspiracy resulted in a loss to the USPS of approximately $39,256.92 over an approximate two-year period.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| More than $39,000Postage lost | The loss to USPS Susan Spiegel admitted when she pleaded guilty.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Spiegel, 70, of Tomball, admitted she caused a loss to U.S. Postal Service (USPS) of more than $39,000.”Open the source |
| Nearly 2000How many | Pieces of outgoing mail investigators examined.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“After examining nearly 2000 individual pieces of outgoing mail”Open the source |
| More than 1,000How many | Single counterfeit stamps seized from the business, besides sheets of online stamps.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Used and re-used sheets of online stamps and more than 1,000 individual counterfeit postage stamps of various denominations were seized from Spiegel’s business.”Open the source |
Where it stands
Susan Spiegel had pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud, as of the release of August 30, 2013.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Susan Spiegel, the former owner of Postal Connections of America, has pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud”Open the source
United States v. Susan Spiegel
The former owner of Postal Connections.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Susan Spiegel, the former owner of Postal Connections of America”Open the source
| Charge |
|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraud, one count, against both defendants togetherDOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“have been charged with one count of conspiracy to commit mail fraud, five counts of mail fraud and 10 counts of possession of counterfeit postage”Open the source |
| Mail fraud, five counts, against both defendants togetherDOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“have been charged with one count of conspiracy to commit mail fraud, five counts of mail fraud and 10 counts of possession of counterfeit postage”Open the source |
| Possession of counterfeit postage, 10 counts, against both defendants togetherDOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“have been charged with one count of conspiracy to commit mail fraud, five counts of mail fraud and 10 counts of possession of counterfeit postage”Open the source |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| December 18, 2012 | Indicted.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Tomball Couple Charged in Connection With Use of Counterfeit PC Postage“The indictment was returned Tuesday, Dec. 18, 2012”Open the source |
| August 30, 2013 | Pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“Susan Spiegel, the former owner of Postal Connections of America, has pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud”Open the source |
What was ordered, agreed, paid or sought
| $39,256.92Forfeiture sought | The forfeiture money judgment for USPS's losses that Susan Spiegel faced at sentencing.DOJ S.D. TEX.: Owner Of “Mail Drop” Convicted Of Manufacturing And Selling Counterfeit Postage“In addition, Spiegel faces a forfeiture money judgment in the amount of $39,256.92 for losses incurred by the USPS.”Open the source |
|---|
More cases of counterfeit stamps
- United States v. Padgett et al.The indictment alleges that from about January 2024 John Patrick Best and Kevin Douglas Padgett bought counterfeit stamps from suppliers in China and resold them online as genuine U.S. flag Forever stamps, which Padgett mailed from post offices in Alabama, and that the scheme took in at least $1.7 million.(M.D. Ala.) · from 2024
- United States v. FisterWayne Fister, of San Diego, bought counterfeit U.S. postage stamps from a seller in China at about 10 percent of the price of genuine stamps and, from about July 2024, sold them as genuine through a seller account on an online marketplace, receiving $6,068,929.No. 3:26-cr-00723 (S.D. Cal.) · from 2024