United States v. Lim
Neal Lim, who owned mail presort companies in the Houston area, and four people who worked for him printed counterfeit postage on customers' mass mailings with altered postage meters, kept the postage the customers paid and claimed presort refunds on that mail. USPS lost more than $14 million from January 2004 to July 2007.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“The scheme involved creating counterfeit postage meter machines to print counterfeit postage on mass mail processed by his presort companies. Illegitimately obtained meters were modified so they would produce counterfeit postage. The businesses collected postage from their mailing customers but didn't pay the post office.”Open the source
- Counterfeit meter postage
- United States v. Lim (S.D. Tex.)
- 4 sources
- Newest source: October 21, 2011
- Who they were
- A mail service provider
- It ran
- January 2004 to July 2007, 42 months
- Postage lost
- More than $14 million
- Investigated by
- The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
- Where it stands
- Neal Lim and his four co-defendants were sentenced.
The scheme
Lim's presort companies printed counterfeit postage on the mass mail they processed, with counterfeit postage meters.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“The scheme involved creating counterfeit postage meter machines to print counterfeit postage on mass mail processed by his presort companies.”Open the source Lim and his co-defendants got postage meters illegitimately and altered them to print counterfeit postage.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“Lim and his co-defendants illegitimately obtained meters which they modified so they would produce counterfeit postage.”Open the source Lim's businesses took postage money from their mailing customers and didn't pay it to the Postal Service.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“The businesses collected postage from their mailing customers but didn't pay the post office.”Open the source
Lim's businesses claimed refunds from the Postal Service for presorting the mail that carried counterfeit postage.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“In addition to profits from the counterfeit postage, Lim's businesses collected additional money for postal refunds from the post office for having pre-sorted the illegally-metered mail.”Open the source
The sources tie together , , , and 4 more (figure 1).
- Neal Lim and Gulf Coast Presort Inc.
Neal Lim owned Gulf Coast Presort.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Lim had been the owner of GCP since November 2002”Open the source
- Neal Lim and Mail Processing Center Inc.
Neal Lim bought Mail Processing Center in 1992.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Lim purchased MPC in 1992”Open the source
- Robert Mungai and Gulf Coast Presort Inc.
Robert Mungai managed Gulf Coast Presort.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Robert Mungai, 41, the manager of MPC and GCP”Open the source
- Robert Mungai and Mail Processing Center Inc.
Robert Mungai managed Mail Processing Center.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Robert Mungai, 41, the manager of MPC and GCP”Open the source
- Ricardo Garciduenas and Gulf Coast Presort Inc.
Ricardo Garciduenas supervised at Gulf Coast Presort.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Ricardo Garciduenas, 57, a supervisor at GCP”Open the source
- David Herrera and Mail Processing Center Inc.
David Herrera was a supervisor at Mail Processing Center.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“David Herrera, 44, supervisor at MPC”Open the source
- David Herrera and Professional Mail Services
David Herrera later owned Professional Mail Services.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“David Herrera, 44, supervisor at MPC and later owner of Professional Mail Services (PMS)”Open the source
- Nicole Garciduenas and Mail Processing Center Inc.
Nicole Garciduenas operated a postage meter at Mail Processing Center.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“Nicole Garciduenas, 30, a postage meter operator at MPC”Open the source
Figure 1. Who and what the scheme tied together. Press a box or a line for what the sources say of it.
How it came to light
The Postal Service sampled the mail it saw processed for Lim's companies and found it was more than the postage available on the companies' licensed meters.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Through a statistical mail sampling process, the USPS determined that the amount of mail observed being processed by the USPS for Lim's companies exceeded the amount of pre-paid postage available on the postage meter machines licensed to Lim's companies”Open the source
After the Postal Service's sampling, postal inspectors monitored the mailings of Lim's companies and the metered postage paid for them, and kept finding more mail processed than postage paid.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“agents with the U.S. Postal Inspection Service, began to monitor the mailings and metered postage paid for Lim’s companies. Upon doing so, the Postal Service continued to observe additional discrepancies between the amount of mail processed and the amount of postage paid.”Open the source
Records shown at trial put the postage Lim paid falling from 2003 to 2007, with no change in his mail volume.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“documentary evidence which showed a declining amount of postage paid by Lim from 2003 - 2007, with no change in mail volume”Open the source
Figure 2 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands.
Figure 2. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.
What it cost
| More than $14 millionPostage lost | Lost revenue to USPS over a four-year period.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“The conspiracy resulted in lost revenue of more than $14 million to the U.S. Postal Service (USPS) over a four-year-period.”Open the source |
|---|
Where it stands
Neal Lim and his four co-defendants were sentenced, as of the release of October 21, 2011.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“sentenced Lim ***earlier this year with the last of the defendants sentenced yesterday***”Open the source
United States v. Neal Lim
Former owner of one of the largest mail presort operations in the Houston area.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“the former owner of one of the largest mail presort operations in the Houston area”Open the source
| Charge |
|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraudDOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Lim was convicted of all seven counts charged against him - conspiracy to commit mail fraud, two counts of mail fraud and four counts of possession of counterfeit postage meter machines”Open the source |
| Two counts of mail fraudDOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Lim was convicted of all seven counts charged against him - conspiracy to commit mail fraud, two counts of mail fraud and four counts of possession of counterfeit postage meter machines”Open the source |
| Four counts of possession of counterfeit postage meter machinesDOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Lim was convicted of all seven counts charged against him - conspiracy to commit mail fraud, two counts of mail fraud and four counts of possession of counterfeit postage meter machines”Open the source |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 17, 2010 | Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“The seven-count indictment was returned under seal by a Houston grand jury on Thursday, June 17, 2010, and unsealed today.”Open the source |
| June 21, 2010 | Arrested the night before the indictment was unsealed, the release of June 22, 2010 says.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“Lim, Mungai and Ricardo Garciduenas were arrested last night by investigating agents”Open the source |
| February 8, 2011 | Found guilty by a jury after a five-day trial, a day before the release that announced it.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“The verdicts were returned yesterday following a five day trial”Open the source |
| June 30, 2011 | Sentenced to a total of 14 years in prison.DOJ SDTX: Former Owner of Houston Mail Presort Operation to Serve Lengthy Prison Term for Stealing Millions from US Postal Service“sentenced Lim, 50, to a total of 14 years imprisonment at a hearing this afternoon”Open the source |
United States v. Robert Mungai
Manager of Mail Processing Center and Gulf Coast Presort, two of Neal Lim's companies.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Robert Mungai, 41, the manager of MPC and GCP”Open the source
| Charge |
|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraudDOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“his four co-defendants pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 17, 2010 | Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“The seven-count indictment was returned under seal by a Houston grand jury on Thursday, June 17, 2010, and unsealed today.”Open the source |
| June 21, 2010 | Arrested the night before the indictment was unsealed, the release of June 22, 2010 says.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“Lim, Mungai and Ricardo Garciduenas were arrested last night by investigating agents”Open the source |
| February 9, 2011 | Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“previously pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| October 20, 2011 | Sentenced to 48 months in prison, as of the release of October 21, 2011, which says the sentence came the day before.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Robert Mungai, 41, the manager of MPC and GCP, was sentenced ***yesterday*** to 48 months imprisonment followed by three years of supervised release.”Open the source |
United States v. David Herrera
Supervisor at Mail Processing Center and later owner of Professional Mail Services, another presort company involved in the scheme.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“David Herrera, 44, supervisor at MPC and later owner of Professional Mail Services (PMS) - another presort company involved in the scheme”Open the source
| Charge |
|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraudDOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“his four co-defendants pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 17, 2010 | Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“The seven-count indictment was returned under seal by a Houston grand jury on Thursday, June 17, 2010, and unsealed today.”Open the source |
| February 9, 2011 | Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“previously pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| October 21, 2011 | Sentenced to 54 months in prison.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“David Herrera, 44, supervisor at MPC and later owner of Professional Mail Services (PMS) - another presort company involved in the scheme, was sentenced to 54 months imprisonment followed by two years of supervised release.”Open the source |
United States v. Nicole Garciduenas
Postage meter operator.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Nicole Garciduenas, 30, a postage meter operator”Open the source
| Charge |
|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraudDOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“his four co-defendants pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 17, 2010 | Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“The seven-count indictment was returned under seal by a Houston grand jury on Thursday, June 17, 2010, and unsealed today.”Open the source |
| February 9, 2011 | Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“previously pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| October 21, 2011 | Sentenced to 27 months in prison.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Nicole Garciduenas, 30, a postage meter operator, and Ricardo Garciduenas, 57, a supervisor at GCP, were sentenced to 27 and 48 months, respectively, each to be followed by three years of supervised release.”Open the source |
United States v. Ricardo Garciduenas
Supervisor at Gulf Coast Presort.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Ricardo Garciduenas, 57, a supervisor at GCP”Open the source
| Charge |
|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraudDOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“his four co-defendants pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 17, 2010 | Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“The seven-count indictment was returned under seal by a Houston grand jury on Thursday, June 17, 2010, and unsealed today.”Open the source |
| June 21, 2010 | Arrested the night before the indictment was unsealed, the release of June 22, 2010 says.DOJ SDTX: Six Indicted in Postage Meter Fraud Scam Resulting in More Than $14 Million in Postage Revenue Loss to U.S. Postal Service“Lim, Mungai and Ricardo Garciduenas were arrested last night by investigating agents”Open the source |
| February 9, 2011 | Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.DOJ SDTX: Owner of Largest Houston Mail Presort Operation Found Guilty of Stealing Millions from USPS in Counterfeit Postage Scheme“previously pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud”Open the source |
| October 21, 2011 | Sentenced to 48 months in prison.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Nicole Garciduenas, 30, a postage meter operator, and Ricardo Garciduenas, 57, a supervisor at GCP, were sentenced to 27 and 48 months, respectively, each to be followed by three years of supervised release.”Open the source |
What was ordered, agreed or paid
| $16 millionRestitution | Restitution Neal Lim was ordered to pay USPS.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Lim was ordered him to pay restitution to the USPS in the amount of $16 million.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| $2 millionRestitution | Restitution ordered to USPS, jointly and severally, against Nicole Garciduenas.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“***Nicole*** Garciduenas was ordered to pay $2 million jointly and severally and a $100 special assessment”Open the source |
| $14,687,237Restitution | Restitution to USPS that Robert Mungai, David Herrera and Ricardo Garciduenas were ordered to pay jointly and severally.DOJ SDTX: Houston Mail Presort Operation Owners and Workers Headed to Federal Prison for Stealing Millions“Mungai, Herrera and ***Ricardo G***. Garciduenas were each ordered to pay jointly and severally $14,687,237 in restitution to the U.S. Postal Service and a $100 special assessment”Open the source |
More cases of counterfeit meter postage
- United States v. ClarkJames H. Clark, Jr., of Las Cruces, New Mexico, who owned and ran a business selling books through websites, copied postage meter stamps he had bought from stamps.com and on October 19, 2010, held 1,527 copies showing $9,142.98 in postage, meant for mailing packages through USPS. USPS's loss came to $365,827.(D.N.M.)
- United States v. MathenyFrom 2013 to 2017 Bradley Jon Matheny, an eBay seller in Marion, Iowa, covered the bottom half of refunded Priority labels with First-Class barcodes and changed the weight on other labels, dropping the packages at the post office dock late in the evening. An expert put USPS's shortfall above $250,000.No. 20-CR-50 (N.D. Iowa) · 2013 to 2017