postalref
Cases

United States v. Lim

Neal Lim, who owned mail presort companies in the Houston area, and four people who worked for him printed counterfeit postage on customers' mass mailings with altered postage meters, kept the postage the customers paid and claimed presort refunds on that mail. USPS lost more than $14 million from January 2004 to July 2007.

Who they were
A mail service provider
It ran
January 2004 to July 2007, 42 months
Postage lost
More than $14 million
Investigated by
The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
Where it stands
Neal Lim and his four co-defendants were sentenced.

The scheme

Lim's presort companies printed counterfeit postage on the mass mail they processed, with counterfeit postage meters. Lim and his co-defendants got postage meters illegitimately and altered them to print counterfeit postage. Lim's businesses took postage money from their mailing customers and didn't pay it to the Postal Service.

Lim's businesses claimed refunds from the Postal Service for presorting the mail that carried counterfeit postage.

The sources tie together , , , and 4 more (figure 1).

  • Neal Lim and Gulf Coast Presort Inc.

    Neal Lim owned Gulf Coast Presort.

  • Neal Lim and Mail Processing Center Inc.

    Neal Lim bought Mail Processing Center in 1992.

  • Robert Mungai and Gulf Coast Presort Inc.

    Robert Mungai managed Gulf Coast Presort.

  • Robert Mungai and Mail Processing Center Inc.

    Robert Mungai managed Mail Processing Center.

  • Ricardo Garciduenas and Gulf Coast Presort Inc.

    Ricardo Garciduenas supervised at Gulf Coast Presort.

  • David Herrera and Mail Processing Center Inc.

    David Herrera was a supervisor at Mail Processing Center.

  • David Herrera and Professional Mail Services

    David Herrera later owned Professional Mail Services.

  • Nicole Garciduenas and Mail Processing Center Inc.

    Nicole Garciduenas operated a postage meter at Mail Processing Center.

How it came to light

The Postal Service sampled the mail it saw processed for Lim's companies and found it was more than the postage available on the companies' licensed meters.

  1. After the Postal Service's sampling, postal inspectors monitored the mailings of Lim's companies and the metered postage paid for them, and kept finding more mail processed than postage paid.

  2. Records shown at trial put the postage Lim paid falling from 2003 to 2007, with no change in his mail volume.

Figure 2 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands.

Ran 42 monthsRan 42 months77 months to a charge77 months to a charge5 charged5 charged3 arrested3 arrested1 convicted1 convicted4 pleaded guilty4 pleaded guilty5 sentenced5 sentenced2004200620082010

Figure 2. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.

What it cost

More than $14 millionPostage lostLost revenue to USPS over a four-year period.

Where it stands

Neal Lim and his four co-defendants were sentenced, as of the release of October 21, 2011.

United States v. Neal Lim

Former owner of one of the largest mail presort operations in the Houston area.

Charge
Conspiracy to commit mail fraud
Two counts of mail fraud
Four counts of possession of counterfeit postage meter machines
DateProceeding
June 17, 2010Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.
June 21, 2010Arrested the night before the indictment was unsealed, the release of June 22, 2010 says.
February 8, 2011Found guilty by a jury after a five-day trial, a day before the release that announced it.
June 30, 2011Sentenced to a total of 14 years in prison.

United States v. Robert Mungai

Manager of Mail Processing Center and Gulf Coast Presort, two of Neal Lim's companies.

Charge
Conspiracy to commit mail fraud
DateProceeding
June 17, 2010Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.
June 21, 2010Arrested the night before the indictment was unsealed, the release of June 22, 2010 says.
February 9, 2011Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.
October 20, 2011Sentenced to 48 months in prison, as of the release of October 21, 2011, which says the sentence came the day before.

United States v. David Herrera

Supervisor at Mail Processing Center and later owner of Professional Mail Services, another presort company involved in the scheme.

Charge
Conspiracy to commit mail fraud
DateProceeding
June 17, 2010Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.
February 9, 2011Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.
October 21, 2011Sentenced to 54 months in prison.

United States v. Nicole Garciduenas

Postage meter operator.

Charge
Conspiracy to commit mail fraud
DateProceeding
June 17, 2010Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.
February 9, 2011Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.
October 21, 2011Sentenced to 27 months in prison.

United States v. Ricardo Garciduenas

Supervisor at Gulf Coast Presort.

Charge
Conspiracy to commit mail fraud
DateProceeding
June 17, 2010Charged in the seven-count indictment returned under seal.
June 21, 2010Arrested the night before the indictment was unsealed, the release of June 22, 2010 says.
February 9, 2011Had pleaded guilty to conspiring to commit mail fraud.
October 21, 2011Sentenced to 48 months in prison.

What was ordered, agreed or paid

$16 millionRestitutionRestitution Neal Lim was ordered to pay USPS.
$2 millionRestitutionRestitution ordered to USPS, jointly and severally, against Nicole Garciduenas.
$14,687,237RestitutionRestitution to USPS that Robert Mungai, David Herrera and Ricardo Garciduenas were ordered to pay jointly and severally.

More cases of counterfeit meter postage