United States v. Matheny
From 2013 to 2017 Bradley Jon Matheny, an eBay seller in Marion, Iowa, covered the bottom half of refunded Priority labels with First-Class barcodes and changed the weight on other labels, dropping the packages at the post office dock late in the evening. An expert put USPS's shortfall above $250,000.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“To reduce his costs, and increase his profit, Matheny possessed and used forged and counterfeited postage meter stamps on many of the packages he sent to his customers between 2013 and 2017.”Open the source
- Counterfeit meter postage
- United States v. Matheny, No. 20-CR-50 (N.D. Iowa)
- 4 sources
- Newest source: December 22, 2023
- Who they were
- A seller shipping its own goods
- It ran
- 2013 to 2017, 48 months
- Postage lost
- $256,441.78
- Investigated by
- The U.S. Postal Inspection Service
- Where it stands
- Sentenced.
The scheme
Counterfeit meter postage
He got Priority Mail handling for packages he had paid only the First-Class rate on.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Convicted of Making Phony Postage“law enforcement learned that Matheny was taking advantage of vulnerabilities in the USPS’s electronic postage payment systems to receive Priority Mail treatment for his packages even though he had only paid the First Class rate.”Open the source He bought postage on eBay's site: he entered a package's details, paid, and printed the digital label on adhesive paper.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 2“Through eBay’s web site, Matheny would input his package specifications, prepay postage, and receive a digital shipping label that he would print on adhesive paper.”Open the source The top of each label showed the mail class paid for, Priority or First-Class, and the bottom held the barcode and tracking number.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 2“The top of the label indicated whether he had paid for first-class or priority shipping; the bottom of the label included a barcode and tracking number.”Open the source
For one order he would buy two labels, one Priority and one First-Class, then void the Priority label and get its full price back.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Subpoenaed eBay records indicated that Matheny routinely purchased two shipping labels for a single order, one priority and the other first class, and then voided the more expensive priority purchase for which he received a full refund.”Open the source He covered the bottom half of the Priority label with the bottom half of the First-Class one, so the label said Priority at the top and carried a First-Class barcode and tracking number.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Matheny had been covering the bottom halves of priority labels with the bottom halves of firstclass labels, thereby producing a hybrid label with a priority shipping designation at the top and a first-class barcode and tracking number at the bottom.”Open the source The Priority marking got the package Priority delivery times, and the First-Class barcode got it scanned and tracked to its destination.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“The priority shipping designation would ensure priority delivery times, and the first-class barcode and tracking number would ensure that the package was scanned and tracked to its destination.”Open the source
He dropped his packages at the post office's back dock later and later in the evening, until he routinely came at about 8:45 p.m.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 2“After that conversation, Matheny began dropping off his packages progressively later, “until routinely he was coming in about a quarter to 9:00.””Open the source That late, staff had no time to look closely at the packages, and sorted them by the mail class printed at the top of the label.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 2“As a result, the staff “didn’t have . . . time to scrutinize the packages.” They would simply sort the packages for priority or first-class delivery according to the designation of shipping class at the top of the label.”Open the source Five of the seven forgery counts were for these spliced labels.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 5“On the other five, the Government claimed that Matheny violated § 501 by making or knowingly using a hybrid shipping label featuring a priority shipping designation but a first-class barcode and tracking number.”Open the source
The appeals court held that the barcode is part of the postage stamp, because it is part of what shows the postage was paid.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 7“The scannable barcodes on the bottom halves of the shipping labels Matheny purchased were part of what made the labels “evidence of prepayment of postage.” See id. Therefore, the barcodes were part of the stamps.”Open the source
Altered postage
On other packages the weight printed on the label had been changed.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Other packages exhibited recorded weights that been altered.”Open the source One 13.1-ounce package had a label bought for 3 ounces with the 3 changed to an 8, partly hidden under a red "DO NOT BEND" stamp.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“For example, one 13.1-ounce package featured a recorded weight of 3 ounces that had been modified to 8 ounces, with a red “DO NOT BEND” stamp partially obscuring the alteration.”Open the source Two of the seven forgery counts were for labels with an altered weight.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 5“On two of the seven counts, the Government claimed that Matheny violated § 501 by making or knowingly using a shipping label with an altered recorded weight.”Open the source
Short-paid postage
On some packages the weight on the label, which set the postage, was less than the package weighed.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Some packages had been “underweighted”; that is, the recorded weight on the label, which determined the postage fee, was less than the actual weight of the package.”Open the source Restitution could cover only the loss from the conduct behind his forgery convictions, so the appeals court held that the loss from underweighting had to come out of it.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 11“Therefore, restitution to the USPS should have been limited to “the loss caused by the specific conduct that is the basis of” Matheny’s forgery convictions. See Hughey, 495 U.S. at 413. Instead, the $256,441.78 restitution award included not only the loss due to Matheny’s forging of stamps but also the loss due to Matheny’s underweighting of packages.”Open the source
The sources tie together , and (figure 1).
- Bradley Jon Matheny and Mathenys
Matheny ran Mathenys from his home in Marion.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“Matheny operated an eBay business known as “Mathenys” from his residence in Marion.”Open the source
- Bradley Jon Matheny and eBay labels
eBay's records showed he often bought a Priority and a First-Class label for one order, then voided the Priority label for a full refund.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Subpoenaed eBay records indicated that Matheny routinely purchased two shipping labels for a single order, one priority and the other first class, and then voided the more expensive priority purchase for which he received a full refund.”Open the source
Figure 1. Who and what the scheme tied together. Press a box or a line for what the sources say of it.
How it came to light
In the fall of 2015 a mail handler brought the post office's manager parcels she said didn't look right: their postage didn't seem to match the service they were getting.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 2“In the fall of 2015, a mail handler approached the manager with “some parcels that she said didn’t look right”—“the postage didn’t seem to match up with the service they were getting.””Open the source
The manager looked over the packages himself, then referred the matter to a postal inspector.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 2“After investigating the packages himself, the manager referred the matter to Inspector Ron Jewell of the Postal Inspection Service.”Open the source
A review of his packages in late 2015 found most had too little postage or a forged meter stamp.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Convicted of Making Phony Postage“A review of Matheny’s packages in late 2015 revealed that most of Matheny’s packages had either insufficient postage or a forged or counterfeited postage meter stamp.”Open the source
Reviews of his packages in 2016 and 2017 found much the same.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“Similar reviews in 2016 and 2017 yielded similar results.”Open the source
Postal inspectors searched his house under a warrant and found a box of First-Class label clippings without their barcodes and tracking numbers.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“In May 2017, postal inspectors executing a search warrant at Matheny’s residence discovered a box full of clippings of first-class labels without barcodes and tracking numbers.”Open the source
The inspector intercepted and examined every piece of mail he sent over one month and found irregularities.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Inspector Jewell intercepted and examined every piece of mail that Matheny sent over a one-month period and discovered several irregularities.”Open the source
Subpoenaed eBay records showed he routinely bought a Priority and a First-Class label for one order, then voided the Priority one for a full refund.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Subpoenaed eBay records indicated that Matheny routinely purchased two shipping labels for a single order, one priority and the other first class, and then voided the more expensive priority purchase for which he received a full refund.”Open the source
During the search, inspectors also seized a handwritten list of crossed-out Priority Mail tracking numbers.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Convicted of Making Phony Postage“During the search, the USPIS seized a large number of unusual paper clippings of partial Priority Mail and First Class postage meter stamps as well as a handwritten list of crossed-out Priority Mail tracking numbers.”Open the source
Law enforcement imaged his devices and found unaltered electronic versions of the forged stamps on his computer.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“Law enforcement also imaged Matheny’s electronic devices and, on his computer, found a number of the unaltered electronic versions of the forged postage meter stamps in question.”Open the source
The inspector zoomed in on his photographs of the spliced labels and saw a crease across the top of the barcode, where a First-Class barcode had been laid over the Priority one.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“To confirm his theory, Inspector Jewell zoomed in on the photographs that he had taken of the hybrid labels. Sure enough, he “could see a little crease line across the top of the barcode” indicating that “First-Class barcodes had been laid over the actual Priority barcode.””Open the source
The inspector matched each First-Class label clipping found in the house to a First-Class barcode and tracking number used under a Priority marking.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 3“Inspector Jewell was able to match each of the first-class label clippings discovered at Matheny’s residence with a first-class barcode and tracking number that Matheny had used with a priority shipping designation.”Open the source
Working with eBay, law enforcement learned he was getting Priority Mail treatment while paying only the First-Class rate.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“Later, working with representatives of eBay, law enforcement learned that Matheny was taking advantage of vulnerabilities in the USPS’s electronic postage payment systems to receive Priority Mail treatment for his packages even though he had only paid the First Class rate.”Open the source
Postal inspectors confronted him.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 4“Postal inspectors eventually confronted Matheny, and he confessed to altering the recorded weights on some labels.”Open the source
Figure 2 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands. A date in the list above pins its bar.
Figure 2. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.
What showed they knew
Said so, in their own words. When postal inspectors confronted him, he confessed to changing the recorded weights on some labels.
“Postal inspectors eventually confronted Matheny, and he confessed to altering the recorded weights on some labels.”
Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022), Page 4Open the source
A court found it showed they knew. The appeals court reasoned that his routinely buying two labels and voiding the Priority one for a refund showed he knew his spliced labels were forgeries that would scan as First-Class.
“the fact that Matheny routinely bought two labels and then voided the priority purchase in order to receive a refund indicates that he knew that the hybrid labels he was using were forgeries that looked like priority labels but would scan as first-class labels.”
Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022), Page 6Open the source
A court found it showed they knew. The appeals court reasoned that his insisting on dropping off packages at the back dock late at night, when staff couldn't look closely at the labels, also showed he knew the labels were forgeries.
“So does the fact that Matheny insisted on dropping off his packages at the back dock late at night when the post-office staff would be unable to scrutinize the labels.”
Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022), Page 6Open the source
What it cost
| More than $250,000Postage lost | What USPS was shorted, as an expert testified at trial.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Convicted of Making Phony Postage“Similar reviews in 2016 and 2017 yielded similar results, and one expert testified that Matheny had shorted the USPS more than $250,000.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| $256,441.78Postage lost | USPS's total loss, as the district court worked it out from the forged labels and the underweighted packages.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“the district court’s calculation of the USPS’s total loss of $256,441.78.”Open the source |
| $387,347.71Face value | Face value of the forged postage over the four years, which the court used in place of USPS's loss to set the sentencing range.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 10“Yet extrapolating from the sample still yielded a total face value of $387,347.71, which is significantly more than $250,000.”Open the source |
| Over 28,000How many | Packages Matheny shipped through USPS in 2015.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“In 2015, for example, Matheny shipped over 28,000 packages with the USPS.”Open the source |
| 2,898How many | Packages he shipped during the USPS review that restitution was worked out from.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“During the USPS review, Matheny shipped 2,898 total packages, of which 384 were posted correctly”Open the source |
| 384How many | Packages in the review with the right postage.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“During the USPS review, Matheny shipped 2,898 total packages, of which 384 were posted correctly”Open the source |
| 1,901How many | Packages in the review with forged labels, some of them also underweighted.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“1,901 had forged labels—which included an indeterminate number of labels that also underweighted the package.”Open the source |
| 613How many | Packages in the review with genuine labels but too low a weight.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“613 had genuine labels but “underweighted” the package by listing a lighter weight than the package’s actual weight”Open the source |
Where it stands
Sentenced, as of the Eighth Circuit's opinion of December 22, 2023, which upheld the restitution he was ordered to pay on remand.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 3““reasonably estimate[ed] the loss” from packages with forged labels, it did not clearly err in making its restitution calculation.”Open the source
United States v. Bradley Jon Matheny
An eBay seller who ran his business from his home.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Convicted of Making Phony Postage“The evidence at trial showed that Matheny operated an eBay business known as “Mathenys” from his residence in Marion.”Open the source
| Charge | |
|---|---|
| Forging or counterfeiting postage meter stampsOpinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 4“a grand jury charged Matheny with eight counts of forging or counterfeiting postage meter stamps in violation of 18 U.S.C § 501”Open the source | 18 U.S.C. § 501 |
| Smuggling goods from the United StatesOpinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 4“three counts of smuggling in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 554, and four additional counts not at issue in this appeal.”Open the source | 18 U.S.C. § 554 |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| March 2, 2021 | Found guilty after a bench trial, having pleaded not guilty and given up a jury: the judge found him guilty of seven counts of forging postage meter stamps and three of smuggling, and acquitted him of the other counts.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 4“Matheny pleaded not guilty and waived his right to trial by jury. At the close of the bench trial, Matheny moved for a judgment of acquittal. The district court denied the motion and found Matheny guilty on seven counts of forging or counterfeiting postage meter stamps and three counts of smuggling. The district court acquitted Matheny on the remaining counts.”Open the source |
| November 12, 2021 | Sentenced to three years in federal prison.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“was sentenced on November 12, 2021, to three years in federal prison.”Open the source |
| July 28, 2022 | The Eighth Circuit upheld his convictions and the rest of his sentence, and set aside the restitution order for the trial court to limit it to the loss from forgery.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 21-3712 (8th Cir. July 28, 2022)Page 13“we affirm Matheny’s convictions, vacate the district court’s restitution order and remand for the district court to limit the restitution award to the loss due to forgery, and otherwise affirm Matheny’s sentence.”Open the source |
| December 22, 2023 | By an amended judgment on remand, entered before the Eighth Circuit's opinion of this day, ordered to pay $192,330.00 in restitution to USPS, 75% of the first award.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“entered an amended judgment ordering Matheny to pay $192,330.00 in restitution to the USPS, representing 75% of the original award.”Open the source |
| December 22, 2023 | The Eighth Circuit upheld the amended restitution.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 3““reasonably estimate[ed] the loss” from packages with forged labels, it did not clearly err in making its restitution calculation.”Open the source |
What was ordered, agreed, paid or sought
| $256,441.78Restitution | Restitution to USPS ordered at sentencing, set aside on appeal.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“He was also ordered to make $256,441.78 in restitution to the USPS.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| $192,330.00Restitution | Restitution to USPS in the amended judgment, limited to the loss from forged labels.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“entered an amended judgment ordering Matheny to pay $192,330.00 in restitution to the USPS, representing 75% of the original award.”Open the source |
| $64,111.78Worked out | Restitution taken off on remand. $256,441.78 minus $192,330.00. |
| $168,210.78Asked on appeal | Restitution Matheny argued for in his second appeal, 65.6% of the first figure, which the court turned down.Opinion, United States v. Matheny, No. 23-1362 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023)Page 2“Matheny appeals, arguing that the correct amount of restitution is $168,210.78, or 65.6% of the original award.”Open the source |
| $10,000Fine | Fine.DOJ NDIA: Marion Man Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Over $250,000 in Phony Postage“Matheny was sentenced to 36 months’ imprisonment and fined $10,000.”Open the source |
More cases of counterfeit meter postage
- United States v. ClarkJames H. Clark, Jr., of Las Cruces, New Mexico, who owned and ran a business selling books through websites, copied postage meter stamps he had bought from stamps.com and on October 19, 2010, held 1,527 copies showing $9,142.98 in postage, meant for mailing packages through USPS. USPS's loss came to $365,827.(D.N.M.)
- United States v. LimNeal Lim, who owned mail presort companies in the Houston area, and four people who worked for him printed counterfeit postage on customers' mass mailings with altered postage meters, kept the postage the customers paid and claimed presort refunds on that mail. USPS lost more than $14 million from January 2004 to July 2007.(S.D. Tex.) · 2004 to 2007