United States v. Caudillo
Since at least 2012, Juan Enrique Caudillo, a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office, took bribes from business mailers, Premier Mailing's owner among them, to approve their bulk mailings as fully paid when the postage was unpaid or short. Losses to USPS came to more than $11.7 million.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Since at least 2012, Caudillo, while working as a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office, took bribes in exchange for approving unpaid or underpaid bulk mail shipments as fully paid.”Open the source
- Permit and bulk mail
- United States v. Caudillo, No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal.)
- 4 sources
- Newest source: October 28, 2021
- Who they were
- A mail service provider
- It ran
- From 2012
- Postage lost
- More than $11.7 million
- Investigated by
- The USPS Office of Inspector General and the U.S. Postal Inspection Service
- Where it stands
- Caudillo was sentenced to 100 months in prison.
The scheme
Permit and bulk mail
From 2012 at the latest, Caudillo worked as a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office and took bribes to approve bulk mailings as fully paid when their postage was unpaid or underpaid.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Since at least 2012, Caudillo, while working as a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office, took bribes in exchange for approving unpaid or underpaid bulk mail shipments as fully paid.”Open the source Premier Mailing's owner paid him to list some of the company's mailings as prepaid. No postage was paid on those mailings at all.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“In one scheme, the owner of Premier Mailing, Inc., a Paramount-based company, paid Caudillo bribes in return for Caudillo falsely listing certain mailings as prepaid, resulting in no postage being paid for them.”Open the source Prosecutors wrote that Caudillo had the mailers fill in paper mailing forms instead of the digital ones, against USPS policy.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“He directed his co-conspirators to use the more cumbersome manual mailing forms rather than the more modern digital ones, exactly the opposite of Postal Service policy”Open the source
On paper, they wrote, the fraud stayed hidden from the computer system that checks the pieces one post office sends against the pieces another receives.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“As a result, [Caudillo’s] fraud was buried in a mountain of paper rather than exposed by a computer system that can easily cross-check the number of pieces of mail sent from one post office with those received at another.”Open the source
Short-paid postage
In a second scheme, another business mailer paid Caudillo to let it underreport information about its mailings, so it paid USPS less for them.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“In a separate scheme, Caudillo accepted bribes to allow another business mailer to underreport information, resulting in reduced payment to the Postal Service for mailings.”Open the source
The sources tie together , , , and 2 more (figure 1).
- Ramon Arribeno and Premier Mailing, Inc.
Its owner.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing”Open the source
- Armando Lopez-Torres and Premier Mailing, Inc.
Its manager.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing”Open the source
- Premier Mailing, Inc. and Juan Enrique Caudillo
Premier Mailing's owner paid Caudillo bribes to list some of its mailings as prepaid, so no postage was paid on them.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“In one scheme, the owner of Premier Mailing, Inc., a Paramount-based company, paid Caudillo bribes in return for Caudillo falsely listing certain mailings as prepaid, resulting in no postage being paid for them.”Open the source
- Juan Enrique Caudillo and Ramon Arribeno
Caudillo's judgment makes him liable for its restitution together with Arribeno.Judgment and Commitment, pages 1 and 2, United States v. Caudillo, No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal. July 6, 2020), ECF 145Page 1“The defendant shall be held jointly and severally liable with co-defendants, Ramon Arribeno, Armando LopezTorres”Open the source
- Juan Enrique Caudillo and Armando Lopez-Torres
Caudillo's judgment makes him liable for its restitution together with Lopez-Torres.Judgment and Commitment, pages 1 and 2, United States v. Caudillo, No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal. July 6, 2020), ECF 145Page 1“The defendant shall be held jointly and severally liable with co-defendants, Ramon Arribeno, Armando LopezTorres”Open the source
- Ramon Arribeno and U.S. bank accounts
The accounts the warrant names are his and his businesses'.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. The U.S. Bank Accounts of Ramon Arribeno and his businesses, No. 2:18-mj-03088 (C.D. Cal.)“United States v. The U.S. Bank Accounts of Ramon Arribeno and his businesses listed below”Open the source
- U.S. bank accounts and Premier Mailing, Inc.
One account was held in Premier Mailing's name.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. The U.S. Bank Accounts of Ramon Arribeno and his businesses, No. 2:18-mj-03088 (C.D. Cal.)“held in the name Premier Mailing Inc.”Open the source
- U.S. bank accounts and Premier Printing & Mailing Inc
Accounts were also held in Premier Printing & Mailing's name.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. The U.S. Bank Accounts of Ramon Arribeno and his businesses, No. 2:18-mj-03088 (C.D. Cal.)“held in the name Premier Printing & Mailing Inc”Open the source
Figure 1. Who and what the scheme tied together. Press a box or a line for what the sources say of it.
How it came to light
The sources don’t say how the case came to light.
A search of Caudillo's home under a warrant found almost $700,000 in cash, which was seized.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“almost $700,000 in cash seized from his residence during a November 2018 search warrant”Open the source
The warrant for the U.S. Bank accounts of Arribeno and his businesses was carried out.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. The U.S. Bank Accounts of Ramon Arribeno and his businesses, No. 2:18-mj-03088 (C.D. Cal.)2:18-mj-03088, ECF 3“Search and Seizure Warrant Executed on 11/28/2018.”Open the source
About $50,000 was seized from Caudillo's bank accounts.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“approximately $50,000 seized from various bank accounts he maintained”Open the source
Figure 2 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands. A date in the list above pins its bar.
Figure 2. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.
What it cost
| More than $11.7 millionPostage lost | Total losses to USPS from the bribes.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“causing more than $11.7 million in total losses to his employer”Open the source |
|---|
Where it stands
Caudillo was sentenced to 100 months in prison, as of the judgment of July 6, 2020. Premier Mailing's owner and manager had pleaded guilty and been sentenced to prison, as of the release of July 1, 2020.Judgment and Commitment, pages 1 and 2, United States v. Caudillo, No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal. July 6, 2020), ECF 145Page 2 · Judgment, ECF 145“the defendant, Juan Enrique Caudillo, is hereby committed on Count 1 of the Indictment to the custody of the Bureau of Prisons for a term of ONE HUNDRED (100) MONTHS.”Open the source
United States v. Juan Enrique Caudillo
A USPS bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Since at least 2012, Caudillo, while working as a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office, took bribes in exchange for approving unpaid or underpaid bulk mail shipments as fully paid.”Open the source
| Charge | |
|---|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraud, count 1 Judgment and Commitment, pages 1 and 2, United States v. Caudillo, No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal. July 6, 2020), ECF 145Page 1 · Judgment, ECF 145“Conspiracy to Commit Mail Fraud, in violation of 18 USC 1349, as charged in Count 1 of the Indictment”Open the source | 18 U.S.C. § 1349 |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| December 2018 | Held in federal custody from December 2018 through his sentencing, as of the release of July 1, 2020.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Caudillo, who has been in federal custody since December 2018”Open the source |
| January 8, 2019 | Charged in case 2:19-cr-00011, which the docket says was filed.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Caudillo, No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal.)“Date Filed: Jan. 8, 2019”Open the source |
| March 2019 | Pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit mail fraud, as of the release of July 1, 2020.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Caudillo pleaded guilty in March 2019 to one count of conspiracy to commit mail fraud.”Open the source |
| July 1, 2020 | Sentenced to 100 months in federal prison.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“was sentenced today to 100 months in federal prison”Open the source |
United States v. Ramon Arribeno
The owner of Premier Mailing.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing”Open the source
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| 2019 | Pleaded guilty to charges for a role in the conspiracy, as of the release of July 1, 2020.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Two co-defendants, Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing, each pleaded guilty in 2019 to charges for their roles in the conspiracy and received federal prison sentences.”Open the source |
| July 1, 2020 | Sentenced to federal prison, as of the release of July 1, 2020, which doesn't give the term.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Two co-defendants, Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing, each pleaded guilty in 2019 to charges for their roles in the conspiracy and received federal prison sentences.”Open the source |
United States v. Armando Lopez-Torres
The manager of Premier Mailing.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing”Open the source
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| 2019 | Pleaded guilty to charges for a role in the conspiracy, as of the release of July 1, 2020.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Two co-defendants, Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing, each pleaded guilty in 2019 to charges for their roles in the conspiracy and received federal prison sentences.”Open the source |
| July 1, 2020 | Sentenced to federal prison, as of the release of July 1, 2020, which doesn't give the term.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Two co-defendants, Ramon Arribeno, 61, of Hacienda Heights, and Armando Lopez-Torres, 63, of the El Sereno neighborhood of the City of Los Angeles, the owner and manager, respectively, of Premier Mailing, each pleaded guilty in 2019 to charges for their roles in the conspiracy and received federal prison sentences.”Open the source |
What was ordered, agreed or paid
| $11,745,608.67Restitution | Restitution Caudillo was ordered to pay, owed jointly and severally with his co-defendants in case 2:20-cr-00081.Judgment and Commitment, pages 1 and 2, United States v. Caudillo, No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal. July 6, 2020), ECF 145Page 1 · Judgment, ECF 145“It is ordered that the defendant shall pay restitution in the total amount of $11,745,608.67 pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3663A.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| Approximately $140,000Restitution | The full balance of Caudillo's Thrift Savings Plan, the 401(k)-type account for federal employees, which he agreed to give up toward restitution along with his pension.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Caudillo, who retired from the U.S. Postal Service last year, also agreed to surrender his pension as restitution, as well as the full balance – approximately $140,000 – of his Thrift Savings Plan, a 401(k)-type account available to federal employees.”Open the source |
| Almost $700,000Forfeiture | Cash seized from Caudillo's home in a November 2018 search, which he agreed to forfeit.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Caudillo has agreed to forfeit almost $700,000 in cash seized from his residence during a November 2018 search warrant.”Open the source |
| Approximately $50,000Forfeiture | Money seized from Caudillo's bank accounts, which he agreed to forfeit.DOJ CDCA: Retired Postal Worker Sentenced to Over 8 Years in Prison for Bribery Scheme Involving Bulk Mail that Caused $11.7 Million in Losses“Caudillo also agreed to forfeit approximately $50,000 seized from various bank accounts he maintained”Open the source |
More cases of permit and bulk mail
- United States v. KaczorowskiSteven Kaczorowski, who managed a bulk mailing company, added a digit to the weight of paid mail on drop-shipment clearance forms, and unpaid mail was buried under paid mail on pallets, so the mail looked paid for while customers were billed for the postage. From at least 2010 to September 2017, more than $1.5 million went unpaid.No. 1:19-cr-00213 (D.N.J.) · 2010 to 2017
- United States v. KussRobert Kuss, managing partner of the mail service provider Creative Marketing Group, filled out and stamped PS Form 8125s himself so bulk mailings he brought to destination USPS facilities looked verified and debited at the Bristol, Connecticut, unit when neither had happened. From about July 2014 to March 2016, at least 125 mailings, 3,260,183 pieces, cost USPS $749,573.No. 3:16-cr-00224 (D. Conn.) · 2014 to 2016
- Presort company's president and production manager, indicted by September 2000The indictment alleges that the president and the production manager of a presort company, a business that prepares mail for others to send, defrauded the Postal Service through a series of postage schemes.
- United States v. Gargano, Patel and LakkamsaniThe two owners of Prodigy Mailing Services, an Illinois bulk-mailing company, forged a Postal clerk's signature on Verification Forms from about March 2010 to February 2015 and stamped them with a USPS date stamp, so over 80 million pieces looked paid, a loss to USPS of at least $16 million.No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.) · 2010 to 2015