United States v. Kaczorowski
Steven Kaczorowski, who managed a bulk mailing company, added a digit to the weight of paid mail on drop-shipment clearance forms, and unpaid mail was buried under paid mail on pallets, so the mail looked paid for while customers were billed for the postage. From at least 2010 to September 2017, more than $1.5 million went unpaid.DOJ DNJ: Former Manager Of Bulk Mailing Company Admits $1.5 Million Mail Fraud Conspiracy“Kaczorowski defrauded the USPS of more than $1.5 million in postage while billing clients as if such postage had been paid.”Open the source
- Permit and bulk mail
- United States v. Kaczorowski, No. 1:19-cr-00213 (D.N.J.)
- 4 sources
- Newest source: July 15, 2020
- Who they were
- A mail service provider
- It ran
- 2010 to September 20, 2017, 86 months
- Postage lost
- More than $1.5 million
- Investigated by
- The U.S. Postal Inspection Service and the USPS Office of Inspector General
- Where it stands
- Steven Kaczorowski was sentenced on October 21, 2019 to 6 months in prison, 3 years of supervised release with 6 months of home detention, and a $15,000 fine.
The scheme
USPS charges less for bulk mail the mailer has already sorted by region or by type of mail. The less sorting USPS has left to do, the bigger the discount.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 1 · ¶ 3“the United States Postal Service ("USPS") offered discounted postage rates when bulk mail was sorted by geographical region and/or type of mail (e.g., first class, second class, etc.) before being deposited to the USPS. In general, the less sorting work required to be done by the USPS, the greater the discount.”Open the source The company often mailed with permit imprint postage: postage information printed in the corner of each piece instead of a stamp or meter strip. Because the imprint carries no postage of its own, the company paid for each mailing in advance from a trust account with USPS.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 2 · ¶ 6“Like many MSPs, the Company frequently used permit imprint postage, which allowed the Company to print postage information on the upper right comer of each mail piece rather than placing stamps or meter strips. Because there was no postage on the permit imprint, the Company paid the postage for each mailing in advance through a trust account with the USPS.”Open the source For each mailing the company filled out a USPS Form 3602 postage statement: the weight of one piece, the number of pieces, the discounts and the postage due. It was then uploaded to USPS's PostalOne! database.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 2 · ¶ 7“the Company recorded the pertinent information on each particular mailing on a USPS Form 3602, Postage Mailing Statement ("USPS Form 3602"), including the type of postage used, the weight of a single mail piece, the number of pieces, the types of discounts and the postage due. The USPS Form 3602 was then electronically uploaded to a USPS database referred to as PostalOne.”Open the source
Taking mail to a USPS plant nearer where it will be delivered, rather than to the local post office, is a plant-verified drop shipment. It is usually done for a further discount.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 3 · ¶ 8“delivery location rather than the local post office. This was called a Plant-Verified Drop Shipment ("PVDS"), and was typically done to obtain further discounted postage rates.”Open the source A postal clerk worked on site at the company, in a detached mail unit. The clerk checked each mailing against its forms and made the entries in PostalOne! that billed the company for the postage.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 3 · ¶ 9“Generally, the Company presented its mail along with the necessary USPS forms to a postal clerk who worked onsite at the Company in what was called a detached mail unit ("DMU"). The postal clerk assigned to the Company's DMU examined the mail and the supporting documentation, including the USPS Form 3602 and, if applicable, the USPS Form 8017 or USPS Form 8125, to determine if the information on the postal forms accurately reflected the makeup of the mailing. The postal clerk subsequently ensured correct postage had been paid by or effected payment by making the appropriate entries in the USPS's electronic database, PostalOne, which caused the Company to be electronically billed for the postage.”Open the source For a drop shipment, the clerk then signed its clearance form, Form 8017 or Form 8125, and stamped the date on it with a round-date stamp: the proof that the mailing had been checked and paid for.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 3 · ¶ 10“Once the postal clerk verified the accuracy of the mailing, the clerk signed or stamped his or her signature on the USPS Form 8017 or USPS Form 8125 and stamped the date with a round-date-ink-stamp in the correct block to prove that the mailing had been verified and the postage paid.”Open the source
When the company brought the mail to the plant, it handed over the original stamped form, which told USPS the postage was already paid.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 3 · ¶ 12“When it ultimately presented the mail to a postal facility for mailing, the Company also presented the original USPS Form 8017 or USPS Form 8125 with the original round-date-ink-stamp, which verified to the USPS that the postage had already been paid.”Open the source At the USPS plant, a dock clerk compared the forms with the count of pallets and trays but didn't weigh the mail again.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 4 · ¶ 14“the USPS dock clerk spot checked the relevant forms against the number of pallets and trays of mail received, but did not reweigh the mail.”Open the source The fraud took several forms, among them reporting fewer pieces than were mailed, changing USPS forms, and adding mail to pallets, trays, tubs or sacks after a postal employee had accepted it and charged and collected its postage.DOJ DNJ: Former Manager Of Bulk Mailing Company Admits $1.5 Million Mail Fraud Conspiracy“committed the fraud by various means, including by underreporting the volume of mail pieces actually mailed, altering USPS forms, and adding mail onto pallets, trays, tubs or sacks after the mail had been accepted and postage assessed and collected by a postal employee.”Open the source
Unpaid mail was buried under a few layers of paid mail on a pallet, so the whole pallet looked paid for.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 5 · ¶ 17(a)“burying unpaid mail beneath a few layers of paid mail. By hiding unpaid mail in pallets of paid mail, the Company intentionally created the misimpression that the postage for the entire pallet of mail had been paid when, in fact, it had not.”Open the source Kaczorowski changed Form 8017, a drop shipment's clearance, by adding a digit to the weight of mail paid for. That made the weight ten times larger, and the company didn't pay postage on much of each shipment.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 8 · ¶ 23(g)“defendant STEVEN KACZOROWSKI altered the USPS Form 8017, Expedited Plant-Load Shipment Clearance, to falsely reflect that a larger amount of mail had been paid and verified than had actually been paid and verified. Specifically, defendant STEVEN KACZOROWSKI did this by adding a digit to the number which indicated the weight in pounds of the paid mail, thereby artificially increasing the weight of the paid mail by a factor of 10. This resulted in the Company failing to pay the postage due on a significant portion of each such shipment of mail.”Open the source The company billed its customers for postage it never paid USPS, on postage statements Kaczorowski made look real with a USPS round-date stamp.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 6 · ¶ 18“postage statements and invoices billing the Company's customers for postage that had not been paid by the Company to the USPS. To create an authentic-looking postage statement, defendant STEVEN KACZOROWSKI used a round-date-ink-stamper, which was the property of the USPS, to create a postmark showing the imprint of the date and origin city of mailing.”Open the source
Customers paid those invoices, mostly by mailing checks to the company.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 6 · ¶ 20“It was further part of the conspiracy that the Company's customers paid such invoices - including the monies fraudulently charged for postage billed but not paid by the Company - primarily by mailing checks to the Company.”Open the source Kaczorowski was paid for his part in cash and in checks written to cash.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 6 · ¶ 22(b)“paid defendant STEVEN KACZOROWSKI in both cash and checks written to cash as compensation”Open the source
The sources tie together , and (figure 1).
- Steven Kaczorowski and a Gloucester County bulk mailing company
Its manager.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 1 · ¶ 1“Defendant STEVEN KACZOROWSKI was employed as the manager of a business in Gloucester County, New Jersey”Open the source
- A Gloucester County bulk mailing company and PNC bank account
The scheme's proceeds went into this account: what customers paid for postage the company never paid USPS.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 6 · ¶ 21“deposited and caused to be deposited the proceeds from this fraudulent scheme into the PNC Bank Account. Such proceeds consisted of payments by the Company's customers for postage billed but not paid to the USPS by the Company.”Open the source
Figure 1. Who and what the scheme tied together. Press a box or a line for what the sources say of it.
How it came to light
The sources don’t say how the case came to light.
Figure 2 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands.
Figure 2. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.
What showed they knew
Told of the problem. Kaczorowski was told about a discrepancy in the weight on the Form 8017 for the July 20, 2016 drop shipment.
“informed defendant STEVEN KACZOROWSKI about the discrepancy in the weight on the USPS Form 8017 pertaining to the July 20, 2016 shipment”
Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019), Page 8 · ¶ 23(h)Open the source
What it cost
| More than $1.5 millionPostage lost | Postage USPS wasn't paid.DOJ DNJ: Former Manager Of Bulk Mailing Company Admits $1.5 Million Mail Fraud Conspiracy“Kaczorowski defrauded the USPS of more than $1.5 million in postage while billing clients as if such postage had been paid.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| $5,815.10Postage lost | Postage the April 25, 2016 mailing's statement said was paid and wasn't.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 7 · ¶ 23(b)“resulting in a loss of $5,815.10 to the USPS.”Open the source |
| About $0.28Worked out | Unpaid postage per piece in the April 25, 2016 mailing. $5,815.10 divided by 20,566 pieces is $0.2828 a piece. |
| $3,433.34Postage lost | Postage the October 20, 2016 mailing's statement said was paid and wasn't.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 8 · ¶ 23(e)“In actuality, the Company did not pay the USPS for such postage, resulting in a loss of $3,433.34 to the USPS.”Open the source |
| About $0.29Worked out | Unpaid postage per piece in the October 20, 2016 mailing. $3,433.34 divided by 12,029 pieces is $0.2854 a piece. |
| Approximately 20,566How many | Pieces in one customer's mailing of April 25, 2016.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 7 · ¶ 23(a)“mailed and caused to be mailed a job for a customer of the Company (hereinafter "Customer l ") involving approximately 20,566 mail pieces.”Open the source |
| Approximately 12,029How many | Pieces in the same customer's mailing of October 20, 2016.Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 7 · ¶ 23(d)“mailed and caused to be mailed a job for Customer 1 involving approximately 12,029 mail pieces.”Open the source |
Where it stands
Steven Kaczorowski was sentenced on October 21, 2019 to 6 months in prison, 3 years of supervised release with 6 months of home detention, and a $15,000 fine, as of the docket's last entry, of July 15, 2020.CourtListener docket: United States v. Kaczorowski, No. 1:19-cr-00213 (D.N.J.)ECF 13“Sentencing held as to STEVEN KACZOROWSKI (1), Count 1, Sentence: Imprisonment 6 months. Supervised Release: 3 years with special conditions including 6 months of home detention. Fine: $15,000.00 due 30 days from date of sentencing. Special Assessment: $100.00.”Open the source
United States v. Steven Kaczorowski
The manager of the bulk mailing company.DOJ DNJ: Former Manager Of Bulk Mailing Company Admits $1.5 Million Mail Fraud Conspiracy“Steven Kaczorowski managed a business that prepared bulk mail”Open the source
| Charge | |
|---|---|
| Conspiracy to commit mail fraud, count 1 Information, United States v. Kaczorowski (D.N.J. Mar. 27, 2019)Page 1 · Caption and the count's heading“STEVEN KACZOROWSKI INFORMATION The defendant having waived in open court prosecution by indictment, the United States Attorney for the District of New Jersey charges: CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT MAIL FRAUD (18 u.s.c. § 1349)”Open the source | 18 U.S.C. § 1349 |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| March 27, 2019 | Pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit mail fraud.DOJ DNJ: Former Manager Of Bulk Mailing Company Admits $1.5 Million Mail Fraud Conspiracy“The mail fraud conspiracy charge to which Kaczorowski pleaded guilty”Open the source |
| October 21, 2019 | Sentenced to 6 months in prison, 3 years of supervised release with 6 months of home detention, and a $15,000 fine due in 30 days.CourtListener docket: United States v. Kaczorowski, No. 1:19-cr-00213 (D.N.J.)ECF 13“13 Oct 21, 2019 Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Renee Marie Bumb: Sentencing held as to STEVEN KACZOROWSKI (1), Count 1, Sentence: Imprisonment 6 months. Supervised Release: 3 years with special conditions including 6 months of home detention. Fine: $15,000.00 due 30 days from date of sentencing. Special Assessment: $100.00.”Open the source |
What was ordered, agreed or paid
| $1.5 millionRestitution | Restitution the company's owner agreed to make for the full loss, paid in full on November 14, 2018.DOJ DNJ: Owner Of Bulk Mailing Company Admits $1.5 Million Mail Fraud Conspiracy“agreed to make restitution for the full amount of the loss, $1.5 million, which was paid in full today.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| More than $1.5 millionRestitution | Restitution Kaczorowski agreed in his plea agreement to make for the full loss, estimated at more than $1.5 million, as the release of March 27, 2019 says; the docket's sentencing and judgment entries list none.DOJ DNJ: Former Manager Of Bulk Mailing Company Admits $1.5 Million Mail Fraud Conspiracy“In his plea agreement, Kaczorowski agreed to make restitution for the full amount of the loss, which is estimated at more than $1.5 million.”Open the source |
| $15,000Fine | The fine in Steven Kaczorowski's sentence, due 30 days from the sentencing.CourtListener docket: United States v. Kaczorowski, No. 1:19-cr-00213 (D.N.J.)ECF 13“Fine: $15,000.00 due 30 days from date of sentencing.”Open the source |
More cases of permit and bulk mail
- United States v. CaudilloSince at least 2012, Juan Enrique Caudillo, a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office, took bribes from business mailers, Premier Mailing's owner among them, to approve their bulk mailings as fully paid when the postage was unpaid or short. Losses to USPS came to more than $11.7 million.No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal.) · from 2012
- United States v. KussRobert Kuss, managing partner of the mail service provider Creative Marketing Group, filled out and stamped PS Form 8125s himself so bulk mailings he brought to destination USPS facilities looked verified and debited at the Bristol, Connecticut, unit when neither had happened. From about July 2014 to March 2016, at least 125 mailings, 3,260,183 pieces, cost USPS $749,573.No. 3:16-cr-00224 (D. Conn.) · 2014 to 2016
- Presort company's president and production manager, indicted by September 2000The indictment alleges that the president and the production manager of a presort company, a business that prepares mail for others to send, defrauded the Postal Service through a series of postage schemes.
- United States v. Gargano, Patel and LakkamsaniThe two owners of Prodigy Mailing Services, an Illinois bulk-mailing company, forged a Postal clerk's signature on Verification Forms from about March 2010 to February 2015 and stamped them with a USPS date stamp, so over 80 million pieces looked paid, a loss to USPS of at least $16 million.No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.) · 2010 to 2015