postalref
Cases

United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani

The two owners of Prodigy Mailing Services, an Illinois bulk-mailing company, forged a Postal clerk's signature on Verification Forms from about March 2010 to February 2015 and stamped them with a USPS date stamp, so over 80 million pieces looked paid, a loss to USPS of at least $16 million.

  • Permit and bulk mail
  • United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani, No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)
  • 5 sources
  • Newest source: January 22, 2026
Who they were
A mail service provider
It ran
March 2010 to February 2015, 59 months
Postage lost
At least approximately $16 million, as alleged
Where it stands
All three defendants pleaded guilty on February 22, 2019 and were sentenced in July 2019.

The scheme

USPS required a Verification Form (Form 8125) for each bulk mailing, showing that its postage had been paid, before the mailing was delivered. A Verification Form had to be signed by a Postal clerk and stamped with a USPS date stamp. To make bulk mailings easier, USPS sometimes ran a detached mail unit at a bulk mailer's own facility.

Prodigy had a detached mail unit on its premises, staffed by a Postal clerk. The information alleges the three defendants forged the signature of the Postal clerk at Prodigy's unit on the Verification Forms, without the clerk's knowledge or permission. The information alleges Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani stamped the Verification Forms with a USPS date stamp, so that the forms looked genuine and checked by a Postal clerk.

The information alleges Patel and Lakkamsani kept unauthorized keys to the locked detached mail unit and to the drawer holding the date stamp, and used them in secret. The information alleges the Verification Forms went with the bulk mailings, by commercial carrier, to post offices around the United States. The information alleges Patel and Lakkamsani gave the Postal clerk daily lists of Prodigy's outgoing bulk mailings and left off the mailings that had no postage paid.

The information alleges the defendants told the energy companies that their money would be used, and was used, to pay postage for their bulk mailings. The information alleges that when bulk mailings went out later than promised, Patel and Lakkamsani had false back-dated Postal receipts made so that the customers' mailings looked on time. The information alleges that at other times Patel and Lakkamsani held back part of some customers' bulk mailings, never mailed it, and kept the postage money for it.

The information alleges the defendants agreed that Gargano would keep about half of the money paid for postage and pay the other half to Patel and Lakkamsani.

The sources tie together , , , and 2 more (figure 1).

  • Yogesh Patel and Prodigy Mailing Services, Inc.

    The information describes Patel as Prodigy's president, owning about 94% of its stock.

  • Arvind Lakkamsani and Prodigy Mailing Services, Inc.

    The information describes Lakkamsani as Prodigy's production manager, owning the other 6% or so of its stock.

  • David Gargano and Direct Mail Resources, Inc.

    The information says Gargano owned and operated Direct Mail Resources.

  • David Gargano and Postmaster Inc. account

    The information says Gargano set up a company and opened a bank account in the name "Postmaster, Inc.".

  • David Gargano and Prodigy Mailing Services, Inc.

    The charges say Gargano referred two energy companies to Prodigy for bulk mailing.

How it came to light

The sources don’t say how the case came to light.

Figure 2 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands.

Ran 59 monthsRan 59 months99 months to a charge99 months to a charge3 charged3 charged3 pleaded guilty3 pleaded guilty3 sentenced3 sentenced2012201420162018

Figure 2. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.

What showed they knew

Acted to hide it. The information alleges that Gargano deposited the energy companies' money into the "Postmaster, Inc." account to hide that it was being kept, so that it looked as if it had gone to USPS.

“in order to conceal the misappropriation of funds, defendant GARGANO utilized a bank account in the name “Postmaster, Inc.” and deposited funds from the Energy Companies into that account, thereby making it falsely appear that those funds were being paid to the Postal Service through the U.S. Postmaster.”

Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018), Page 6 · ¶ 15Open the source

What it cost

At least approximately $16 millionPostage lostLoss to USPS alleged in the information, in bulk mailing delivery for which no postage was paid.
More than 80 millionHow manyPieces of mail in the bulk mailings the information says were obtained from USPS.
At least approximately $16 millionTaken inPostage money from the energy companies and other customers that the information alleges the defendants kept for themselves, their families and their businesses.

Where it stands

All three defendants pleaded guilty on February 22, 2019 and were sentenced in July 2019, as of the dockets' newest entry, of January 22, 2026.

United States v. Yogesh Patel

The information describes him as an owner of Prodigy Mailing Services, a bulk-mailing company, and its president, holding about 94% of its stock.

Charge
Mail fraud, count 1 
DateProceeding
June 25, 2018Charged by a criminal information with one count of mail fraud.
February 22, 2019Pleaded guilty to the information, and the court entered a finding of guilty.
July 10, 2019Sentenced to 42 months in prison.

United States v. Arvind Lakkamsani

The information describes him as an owner of Prodigy Mailing Services and its production manager, holding about 6% of its stock.

Charge
Mail fraud, count 1 
DateProceeding
June 25, 2018Charged by a criminal information with one count of mail fraud.
February 22, 2019Pleaded guilty to the information, and the court entered a finding of guilty.
July 12, 2019Sentenced to five years of probation, the first 24 months on home detention.

United States v. David Gargano

The information describes him as the owner of Direct Mail Resources, a broker that matched customers wanting bulk mailings with bulk-mailing companies such as Prodigy, for a fee.

Charge
Mail fraud, count 1 
DateProceeding
June 25, 2018Charged by a criminal information with one count of mail fraud.
February 22, 2019Pleaded guilty to the information, and the court entered a finding of guilty.
July 10, 2019Sentenced to 48 months in prison.

What was ordered, agreed or paid

$16,961,820.00RestitutionRestitution each of the three judgments of July 16, 2019 orders, as Lakkamsani's entry prints it.

More cases of permit and bulk mail