United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani
The two owners of Prodigy Mailing Services, an Illinois bulk-mailing company, forged a Postal clerk's signature on Verification Forms from about March 2010 to February 2015 and stamped them with a USPS date stamp, so over 80 million pieces looked paid, a loss to USPS of at least $16 million.DOJ ILND: Federal Charges Accuse Owners of Suburban Bulk-Mailing Company of Defrauding the Postal Service out of $16 Million“The owners of a suburban bulk-mailing company swindled the U.S. Postal Service out of at least $16 million by forging documents and secretly using an official date stamp to fraudulently authenticate payment of postage for than 80 million pieces of mail, according to criminal charges filed today by the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Chicago”Open the source
- Permit and bulk mail
- United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani, No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)
- 5 sources
- Newest source: January 22, 2026
- Who they were
- A mail service provider
- It ran
- March 2010 to February 2015, 59 months
- Postage lost
- At least approximately $16 million, as alleged
- Where it stands
- All three defendants pleaded guilty on February 22, 2019 and were sentenced in July 2019.
The scheme
USPS required a Verification Form (Form 8125) for each bulk mailing, showing that its postage had been paid, before the mailing was delivered.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 2 · ¶ 1(g)“The Postal Service required that a Verification Form (Form 8125) be completed for each bulk mailing before delivery to verify that payment for the bulk mailing had been made to the Postal Service.”Open the source A Verification Form had to be signed by a Postal clerk and stamped with a USPS date stamp.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 2 · ¶ 1(g)“The Verification Form had to be signed by a Postal clerk and date-stamped with a Postal Service date-stamp”Open the source To make bulk mailings easier, USPS sometimes ran a detached mail unit at a bulk mailer's own facility.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 2 · ¶ 1(h)“In order to facilitate bulk mailings, the Postal Service sometimes operated a detached mail unit (“unit”) at bulk mailing companies.”Open the source
Prodigy had a detached mail unit on its premises, staffed by a Postal clerk.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 3 · ¶ 1(i)“Prodigy had a detached mail unit on its premises, which was staffed by a Postal clerk.”Open the source The information alleges the three defendants forged the signature of the Postal clerk at Prodigy's unit on the Verification Forms, without the clerk's knowledge or permission.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 4 · ¶ 5“forged and caused to be forged on the Verification Forms the signature of a Postal clerk who worked at the detached mail unit in the Prodigy facility, without that clerk’s knowledge or permission.”Open the source The information alleges Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani stamped the Verification Forms with a USPS date stamp, so that the forms looked genuine and checked by a Postal clerk.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 4 · ¶ 6“defendants GARGANO, PATEL, and LAKKAMSANI used, and caused to be used, a date-stamp that belonged to the Postal Service to stamp the Verification Forms, making it falsely appear that the Forms were authentic and had been verified by a Postal clerk.”Open the source
The information alleges Patel and Lakkamsani kept unauthorized keys to the locked detached mail unit and to the drawer holding the date stamp, and used them in secret.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 4 · ¶ 7“fraudulently maintained unauthorized keys to the locked detached mail unit and the cabinet drawer that held the date-stamp, and secretly used those keys to gain entry”Open the source The information alleges the Verification Forms went with the bulk mailings, by commercial carrier, to post offices around the United States.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 5 · ¶ 8“mailings, through a commercial interstate carrier, to post offices around the United States for delivery of the bulk mailings.”Open the source The information alleges Patel and Lakkamsani gave the Postal clerk daily lists of Prodigy's outgoing bulk mailings and left off the mailings that had no postage paid.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 5 · ¶ 9“provided to the Postal Clerk, who worked at the detached mail unit, daily lists of bulk mailings being sent out by Prodigy, and defendants PATEL and LAKKAMSANI intentionally did not identify the bulk mailings being sent out by Prodigy with no postage having been paid, thereby fraudulently concealing those bulk mailings.”Open the source
The information alleges the defendants told the energy companies that their money would be used, and was used, to pay postage for their bulk mailings.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 5 · ¶ 10“falsely represented, and caused others to falsely represent, to the Energy Companies that their funds would be used, and were used, to pay postage for their bulk mailings”Open the source The information alleges that when bulk mailings went out later than promised, Patel and Lakkamsani had false back-dated Postal receipts made so that the customers' mailings looked on time.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 5 · ¶ 12“created, and caused to be created, false back-dated Postal mailing receipts, which were sent to certain customers, in order to make it falsely appear that the customers’ bulk mailings had been mailed on time.”Open the source The information alleges that at other times Patel and Lakkamsani held back part of some customers' bulk mailings, never mailed it, and kept the postage money for it.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 6 · ¶ 12“held back, and did not mail, a portion of certain customers’ bulk mailings, and misappropriated the funds relating to the postage for those portions of the bulk mailings.”Open the source
The information alleges the defendants agreed that Gargano would keep about half of the money paid for postage and pay the other half to Patel and Lakkamsani.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 6 · ¶ 14“defendant GARGANO kept approximately 50% of the money paid for postage funds and paid the remaining approximately 50% to defendants PATEL and LAKKAMSANI.”Open the source
The sources tie together , , , and 2 more (figure 1).
- Yogesh Patel and Prodigy Mailing Services, Inc.
The information describes Patel as Prodigy's president, owning about 94% of its stock.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · ¶ 1(b)“Defendant PATEL was the President of the company and owned approximately 94% of its stock.”Open the source
- Arvind Lakkamsani and Prodigy Mailing Services, Inc.
The information describes Lakkamsani as Prodigy's production manager, owning the other 6% or so of its stock.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · ¶ 1(b)“Defendant LAKKAMSANI was the Production Manager and owned the remaining approximately 6% of the stock.”Open the source
- David Gargano and Direct Mail Resources, Inc.
The information says Gargano owned and operated Direct Mail Resources.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · ¶ 1(c)“Defendant DAVID GARGANO owned and operated Direct Mail Resources, Inc.”Open the source
- David Gargano and Postmaster Inc. account
The information says Gargano set up a company and opened a bank account in the name "Postmaster, Inc.".Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 2 · ¶ 1(f)“Defendant GARGANO created a company and opened a bank account in the name of “Postmaster, Inc.”.”Open the source
- David Gargano and Prodigy Mailing Services, Inc.
The charges say Gargano referred two energy companies to Prodigy for bulk mailing.DOJ ILND: Federal Charges Accuse Owners of Suburban Bulk-Mailing Company of Defrauding the Postal Service out of $16 Million“Gargano referred two energy companies to Prodigy for bulk mailing services.”Open the source
Figure 1. Who and what the scheme tied together. Press a box or a line for what the sources say of it.
How it came to light
The sources don’t say how the case came to light.
Figure 2 sets the case to scale, from the scheme’s first day to where it stands.
Figure 2. The case to scale. Press a bar or a point for what the sources say of it.
What showed they knew
Acted to hide it. The information alleges that Gargano deposited the energy companies' money into the "Postmaster, Inc." account to hide that it was being kept, so that it looked as if it had gone to USPS.
“in order to conceal the misappropriation of funds, defendant GARGANO utilized a bank account in the name “Postmaster, Inc.” and deposited funds from the Energy Companies into that account, thereby making it falsely appear that those funds were being paid to the Postal Service through the U.S. Postmaster.”
Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018), Page 6 · ¶ 15Open the source
What it cost
| At least approximately $16 millionPostage lost | Loss to USPS alleged in the information, in bulk mailing delivery for which no postage was paid.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 6 · ¶ 17“fraudulently obtained bulk mailing services without paying any postage for those mailings, thereby causing a loss to the Postal Service of at least approximately $16 million.”Open the source |
|---|---|
| More than 80 millionHow many | Pieces of mail in the bulk mailings the information says were obtained from USPS.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 3 · ¶ 3“based on bulk mailings of more than 80 million pieces of mail”Open the source |
| At least approximately $16 millionTaken in | Postage money from the energy companies and other customers that the information alleges the defendants kept for themselves, their families and their businesses.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 6 · ¶ 13“misappropriated for their own benefit and the benefit of their families and businesses at least approximately $16 million that the Energy Companies and other customers submitted for payment of bulk mailing postage.”Open the source |
Where it stands
All three defendants pleaded guilty on February 22, 2019 and were sentenced in July 2019, as of the dockets' newest entry, of January 22, 2026.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano (third docket), No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 71“JUDGMENT (Sentencing Order) as to Arvind Lakkamsani (3), Count(s) 1, The defendant shall be on probation for a term of Five (5) years with the first 24 months on Home Detention. The defendant must pay the total restitution amount of $16,961,820.00.”Open the source
United States v. Yogesh Patel
The information describes him as an owner of Prodigy Mailing Services, a bulk-mailing company, and its president, holding about 94% of its stock.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · ¶ 1(b)“Defendant PATEL was the President of the company and owned approximately 94% of its stock.”Open the source
| Charge | |
|---|---|
| Mail fraud, count 1 Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · Caption“Violation: Title 18, United States Code Section 1341”Open the source | 18 U.S.C. § 1341 |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 25, 2018 | Charged by a criminal information with one count of mail fraud.DOJ ILND: Federal Charges Accuse Owners of Suburban Bulk-Mailing Company of Defrauding the Postal Service out of $16 Million“A criminal information charges each of the three defendants – Patel, 58, of Orlando, Fla., Lakkamsani, 57, of Northbrook, Ill., and Gargano, 51, of Barrington, Ill. – with one count of mail fraud.”Open the source |
| February 22, 2019 | Pleaded guilty to the information, and the court entered a finding of guilty.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano (second docket), No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 38“38 Feb 22, 2019 ORDER as to Yogesh Patel: Change of plea hearing held. Defendant informed of his rights. Defendant enters plea of guilty to Information. Finding of guilty entered.”Open the source |
| July 10, 2019 | Sentenced to 42 months in prison.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano (second docket), No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 67“67 Jul 11, 2019 MINUTE entry before the Honorable Sara L. Ellis as to Yogesh Patel: Sentencing held on 7/10/2019. Defendant sentenced to 42 months imprisonment. Judgment in a criminal case to follow.”Open the source |
United States v. Arvind Lakkamsani
The information describes him as an owner of Prodigy Mailing Services and its production manager, holding about 6% of its stock.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · ¶ 1(b)“Defendant LAKKAMSANI was the Production Manager and owned the remaining approximately 6% of the stock.”Open the source
| Charge | |
|---|---|
| Mail fraud, count 1 Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · Caption“Violation: Title 18, United States Code Section 1341”Open the source | 18 U.S.C. § 1341 |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 25, 2018 | Charged by a criminal information with one count of mail fraud.DOJ ILND: Federal Charges Accuse Owners of Suburban Bulk-Mailing Company of Defrauding the Postal Service out of $16 Million“A criminal information charges each of the three defendants – Patel, 58, of Orlando, Fla., Lakkamsani, 57, of Northbrook, Ill., and Gargano, 51, of Barrington, Ill. – with one count of mail fraud.”Open the source |
| February 22, 2019 | Pleaded guilty to the information, and the court entered a finding of guilty.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano (third docket), No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 39“39 Feb 22, 2019 ORDER as to Arvind Lakkamsani: Change of plea hearing held. Defendant informed of his rights. Defendant enters plea of guilty to Information. Finding of guilty entered.”Open the source |
| July 12, 2019 | Sentenced to five years of probation, the first 24 months on home detention.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano (third docket), No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 68“68 Jul 12, 2019 MINUTE entry before the Honorable Sara L. Ellis as to Arvind Lakkamsani: Sentencing held on 7/12/2019. Defendant sentenced to 5 years probation with first 24 months on home detention. Judgment in a criminal case to follow.”Open the source |
United States v. David Gargano
The information describes him as the owner of Direct Mail Resources, a broker that matched customers wanting bulk mailings with bulk-mailing companies such as Prodigy, for a fee.Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · ¶ 1(c)“Defendant DAVID GARGANO owned and operated Direct Mail Resources, Inc., which for a fee acted as a broker matching customers wanting to make bulk mailings with bulk mailing companies such as Prodigy.”Open the source
| Charge | |
|---|---|
| Mail fraud, count 1 Information, United States v. Gargano, Patel and Lakkamsani (N.D. Ill. June 25, 2018)Page 1 · Caption“Violation: Title 18, United States Code Section 1341”Open the source | 18 U.S.C. § 1341 |
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| June 25, 2018 | Charged by a criminal information with one count of mail fraud.DOJ ILND: Federal Charges Accuse Owners of Suburban Bulk-Mailing Company of Defrauding the Postal Service out of $16 Million“A criminal information charges each of the three defendants – Patel, 58, of Orlando, Fla., Lakkamsani, 57, of Northbrook, Ill., and Gargano, 51, of Barrington, Ill. – with one count of mail fraud.”Open the source |
| February 22, 2019 | Pleaded guilty to the information, and the court entered a finding of guilty.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano, No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 37“37 Feb 22, 2019 ORDER as to David Gargano: Change of plea hearing held. Defendant informed of his rights. Defendant enters plea of guilty to Information. Finding of guilty entered.”Open the source |
| July 10, 2019 | Sentenced to 48 months in prison.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano, No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 61“61 Jul 10, 2019 MINUTE entry before the Honorable Sara L. Ellis as to David Gargano: Sentencing held on 7/10/2019. Defendant sentenced to 48 months imprisonment. Judgment in a criminal case to follow.”Open the source |
What was ordered, agreed or paid
| $16,961,820.00Restitution | Restitution each of the three judgments of July 16, 2019 orders, as Lakkamsani's entry prints it.CourtListener RECAP docket: United States v. Gargano (third docket), No. 1:18-cr-00392 (N.D. Ill.)ECF 71“JUDGMENT (Sentencing Order) as to Arvind Lakkamsani (3), Count(s) 1, The defendant shall be on probation for a term of Five (5) years with the first 24 months on Home Detention. The defendant must pay the total restitution amount of $16,961,820.00.”Open the source |
|---|
More cases of permit and bulk mail
- United States v. CaudilloSince at least 2012, Juan Enrique Caudillo, a bulk mail clerk at the Paramount post office, took bribes from business mailers, Premier Mailing's owner among them, to approve their bulk mailings as fully paid when the postage was unpaid or short. Losses to USPS came to more than $11.7 million.No. 2:19-cr-00011 (C.D. Cal.) · from 2012
- United States v. KaczorowskiSteven Kaczorowski, who managed a bulk mailing company, added a digit to the weight of paid mail on drop-shipment clearance forms, and unpaid mail was buried under paid mail on pallets, so the mail looked paid for while customers were billed for the postage. From at least 2010 to September 2017, more than $1.5 million went unpaid.No. 1:19-cr-00213 (D.N.J.) · 2010 to 2017
- United States v. KussRobert Kuss, managing partner of the mail service provider Creative Marketing Group, filled out and stamped PS Form 8125s himself so bulk mailings he brought to destination USPS facilities looked verified and debited at the Bristol, Connecticut, unit when neither had happened. From about July 2014 to March 2016, at least 125 mailings, 3,260,183 pieces, cost USPS $749,573.No. 3:16-cr-00224 (D. Conn.) · 2014 to 2016
- Presort company's president and production manager, indicted by September 2000The indictment alleges that the president and the production manager of a presort company, a business that prepares mail for others to send, defrauded the Postal Service through a series of postage schemes.